Search lotsAny category · Ships to United States
United States · Any format
All Women Men Shoes Beauty Bags

Olay Makeup resale prices & live listings

Every price below comes from real sales, not from a guide.

Resale value, retail and wholesale · last 12 months

What Olay makeup sells for

Olay makeup sells for a median $8 used and $18 new with tags on Poshmark.

Based on sales we tracked on Poshmark, last 12 months · Updated Nov 15, 2026 · How we price →

$12median sold price
35 daysmedian time to sell
A typical Olay makeup piece resale
Sold price$12
Days to sell35
New with tags vs used$18 / $8
Share of listings that sell41 %
Sep ’25 to Sep ’26period of the sales we tracked
$8 to $2420 to 80 % band of sold prices
41 %sell-through: of listings from the last year, sold
72 %of active listings older than 90 days

Olay makeup worth, a piece

Medians of completed sales, the retail price of new listings and the lowest live wholesale price a piece on Closo, each named by where it was measured.

New

New with tags · sold on Poshmark$18median of sales we tracked, last 12 months

Pre-owned or any condition

Used · sold on Poshmark$8median of sales we tracked, last 12 months
Olay makeup prices: resale value, retail and wholesale · Data as of Nov 15, 2026Retail and resale prices are medians, with the middle of the prices (20th to 80th percentile) as the range. Closo Wholesale shows the lowest price a piece among live lots.
WhereConditionPriceRangeBasisAs of
New
PoshmarkNew with tags, women’s$18$10 to $25Sold, last 12 monthsNov 15
Pre-owned or any condition
PoshmarkAny condition$12$8 to $24Sold, last 12 monthsNov 15
PoshmarkUsed$8$6 to $10Sold, last 12 monthsNov 15

Changes compare the last 90 days with the 90 before.

Tracked sales per monthSep ’25 to Sep ’26
Sep ’25Oct ’25 · median $29 · 28 daysNov ’25 · median $30 · 34 daysDec ’25 · median $10 · 35 daysJan ’26 · median $20 · 15 daysFeb ’26 · median $18 · 9 daysMar ’26 · median $8 · 30 daysApr ’26 · median $24 · 20 daysMay ’26 · median $12 · 91 daysJun ’26 · median $32 · 94 daysJul ’26 · median $4 · 47 daysAug ’26 · median $8 · 365+ daysSep ’26 · median $12 · 2 days
vs prior 30 days: −100 % sales we tracked in the last 30 days against the 30 before
Season

When Olay makeup sells

Olay makeup sells in spring and summer: Mar, Apr and Aug carried 50 % of the year’s sales, with the peak in Mar ’26.

The last 30 days ran 100 % below the 30 before them.

Listed vs sold · Poshmark

Olay makeup market

Buyer's marketPlenty listed, slow to sell
17months of supply

Poshmark listings as of Nov 15, 2026

For resellersPrice to sell: more is listed than sells in a year.

Compared with

Women › Makeup, same 12 months: the category as a whole, and the two brands whose sold prices overlap Olay’s band.

Category median · all brands

$17median sold price

Sells in 48 days, 36 % sell-through.

Typology makeup

$30median sold price

Sells in 9 days, 97 % sell-through.

Smooche makeup

$19median sold price

Sells in 43 days, 94 % sell-through.

Recently sold

8 newest Olay makeup sales. Titles as the sellers wrote them, trimmed.

  • Olay Total Effects 7-in-One Tone Correcting CC Cream SPF 15 Light to…Olay Total Effects 7-in-One Tone Correcting CC Cream SPF 15 Light to…$17OSUsedNov 8
  • Olay Total Effects 7-in-One Tone Correcting CC Cream SPF 15 Light to…Olay Total Effects 7-in-One Tone Correcting CC Cream SPF 15 Light to…$17OSUsedNov 8
  • Olay Total Effects 7-in-One Tone Correcting CC Cream SPF 15 Light to…Olay Total Effects 7-in-One Tone Correcting CC Cream SPF 15 Light to…$17OSUsedNov 7
  • CC Tinted Serum Light NWTCC Tinted Serum Light NWT$10OSUsedNov 6
  • OLAY Super Eyes Daily Eye Serum - White and Rose Gold PackagingOLAY Super Eyes Daily Eye Serum - White and Rose Gold Packaging$60OSUsedOct 19
  • OLAY Super Eyes Daily Eye Serum - White and Rose Gold PackagingOLAY Super Eyes Daily Eye Serum - White and Rose Gold Packaging$60OSUsedOct 19
  • OLAY Regenerist Eye Serum Tube – NewOLAY Regenerist Eye Serum Tube – New$12OSUsedSep 16
  • OLAY Super Serum - Pink Iridescent BottleOLAY Super Serum - Pink Iridescent Bottle$14OSUsedSep 5

Photos and titles belong to the sellers who listed them on Poshmark.

Buying Olay makeup in bulk?

2 wholesale lots carry Olay Makeup. Escrow-protected checkout.

Demand · Closo Research

Makeup resale demand, Aug 2026.Data through Aug 2026 · Preliminary

52.5Search interest index, 2024 = 100
-29.8%vs. a year ago
27%Sell-through rate
See the full index

Closest live Olay lots right now

2 wholesale lots carry Olay Makeup See all →
Olay Beauty Fluid Regular 100ml New 3 days ago
$2,145
Olay Beauty Fluid Regular 100ml Bulk Buy America New Jersey
Olay – Ultra Moisture Body Wash with Shea Butter, 3 fl oz – 24 Pack
$47Resale ~$360
Olay – Ultra Moisture Body Wash with Shea Butter, 3 fl oz – 24 Pack Contarmarket 4.1 (71) Florida
Olay - Facial Cleanser and Detoxifying Pore Scrub - Duo Pack
$28
Olay - Facial Cleanser and Detoxifying Pore Scrub - Duo Pack Contarmarket 4.1 (71) Florida

Compare resale prices nearby

The brands and categories closest to Olay Makeup, each with its median sold price, its sales, its live listings or its monthly searches.

Makeup brands A to Z →

Related on Closo

About these numbers

FAQ

Olay Makeup — questions buyers ask

Answers come from live Closo listings and real sales, not from marketing copy.

The numbers in one paragraph

2 wholesale lots carry Olay Makeup on the manifest or in the listing, from vetted U.S. liquidators with escrow on every order.

How much does Olay makeup sell for?
Olay makeup sells for a median $12 on Poshmark over the last 12 months — $8 used and $18 new with tags. Most Poshmark sales landed between $8 and $24. The numbers are measured on completed sales, not taken from a price guide.
How much is Olay makeup worth?
A typical Olay makeup resale is worth about $8 used and $18 new with tags on Poshmark.
Where can I buy Olay makeup wholesale or in bulk?
On Closo: 2 live wholesale lots carry Olay Makeup on the manifest or in the listing. Every lot comes from a vetted U.S. liquidator, is paid into escrow, and freight is quoted for your ZIP before you pay.
Where do these prices come from?
From completed sales on Poshmark, refreshed daily; see How we price.

Explore wholesale