Magic: The Gathering Toys resale prices & live listings
Magic: The Gathering Toys resold for a median $6 over the last 12 months. Every price below comes from real sales, not from a guide.
What Magic: The Gathering toys sell for
Magic: The Gathering toys sell for a median $6 used on Poshmark.
Based on sales we tracked on Poshmark, last 12 months · Updated Oct 14, 2026 · Data as of Oct 13, 2026 · How we price →
Magic: The Gathering toys worth, a piece
Medians of completed sales, the retail price of new listings and the lowest live wholesale price a piece on Closo — each named by where it was measured.
Pre-owned or any condition
| Where | Condition | Price | Range | Basis | As of |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Pre-owned or any condition | |||||
| Poshmark | Any condition | $6 | $6–$6 | Sold, last 12 months | Oct 13 |
| Poshmark | Used | $6 | $6–$6 | Sold, last 12 months | Oct 13 |
Changes compare the last 90 days with the 90 before.
When Magic: The Gathering toys move
Magic: The Gathering toys sell in spring and summer: Apr, May and Aug carried 100 % of the year’s sales, with the peak in May ’26.
Listed vs sold · Poshmark
Magic: The Gathering toys market
Poshmark listings as of Oct 13, 2026
For resellersPrice to sell: more is listed than sells in a year.
Compared with
Kids › Toys, same 12 months: the category as a whole, and the two brands whose sold prices overlap Magic: The Gathering’s band.
Category median · all brands
Sells in 35 days, 20 % sell-through.
Skip Hop toys
Sells in 57 days, 46 % sell-through.
Eric Carle toys
Sells in 32 days, 43 % sell-through.
Recently sold
2 newest Magic: The Gathering toys sales. Titles as the sellers wrote them, trimmed.
Magic The Gathering Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles Commander Deck Turtl…$66OS (Baby)UsedAug 27
Magic The Gathering Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles Commander Deck Turtl…$66OS (Baby)UsedAug 26
Photos and titles belong to the sellers who listed them on Poshmark.
Related by sales
Kids › Toys brands whose sold prices overlap $6–$6, by sell-through. Each card opens the brand’s Closo hub.
Buying Magic: The Gathering toys in bulk?
No wholesale lot carries Magic: The Gathering on the manifest right now.
Suppliers of Toys in the registry
Wholesale toys suppliers on record — how long each has been online, what buyers said, and what each has live on Closo right now.
Compare resale prices nearby
The brands and categories closest to Magic: The Gathering Toys, each with its median sold price, its sales, its live listings or its monthly searches.
Similar brands by sales
- Topps Toys$24
- Matchbox Toys$9
- Baby Three Toys$14
- LeapFrog Toys$10
- Pokemon Toys$14
- Activision Toys$12
- Crayola Toys$10
- Dr. Seuss Toys$12
- PEZ Toys$7
- Scholastic Toys$8
- Hot Wheels Toys$10
Magic: The Gathering in other categories
Nearby categories
- Accessories$18
- Shirts & Tops$12
- Pajamas$14
- Shoes$30
- Bottoms$12
- Dresses$25
- Matching Sets$15
- Costumes$16
- One Pieces$13
- Jackets & Coats$28
- Swim$20
Related on Closo
About these numbers
Months of supply
Under 3 months is a seller's market, 3 to 6 balanced, over 6 a buyer's.
How this is measured
Poshmark listings live on the date the block shows (every seller, not only Closo shops), divided by an average month of the 12-month sales in “What Magic: The Gathering toys sell for”.
Magic: The Gathering Toys — questions buyers ask
Answers come from live Closo listings and real sales, not from marketing copy.
