Jellycat vs Mattel toys: resale price, speed and wholesale lots

Jellycat toys resell for more and faster: a $27 median in 18 days, against $15 in 33 days for Mattel. Used items, Poshmark sales, last 12 months.

Shop toys lots Get lot alerts
$27 vs $15median sold price, Jellycat vs Mattel
18 vs 33 daysmedian time to sell
61% vs 18%sell-through, last 12 months
−44% vs −28%sales, last 30 days vs the 30 before

Side by side

Same marketplace, same 12 months, used kids' toys only. Green marks the better figure for a reseller.

JellycatMattel
Median sold price$27$15
Typical sold price, middle half$17–$45$10–$27
Median time to sell18 days33 days
Sell-through61%18%
Sales, last 30 days vs the 30 before−44%−28%
Median sold price, new with tags$40$20
Brand hubJellycat toysMattel toys

Sold price is the last listed price of a sold item. A brand pair page opens only when both brands have 300+ used sales in 12 months.

Buy Jellycat and Mattel in bulk

Jellycat Bashful Giraffe Stuffed Animal, Medium 12 inches – Safari Plush Toy – Classic Children’s Gift 4 photos
Manifested
Jellycat Bashful Giraffe Stuffed Animal, Medium 12 inches – Safari Plush Toy – Classic Children’s Gift 45 units · NWT · Ships parcel
American Wholesale LLC 4.5 (22)
$1,733 $38.50 / piece
View lot
Lot of 2 Polly Pocket Cars Purple Pink Convertible 2003 Mattel *Damaged 8 photos
Assortment
Lot of 2 Polly Pocket Cars Purple Pink Convertible 2003 Mattel *Damaged 2 units · Used · Ships parcel
Thrift World
$20 $10.12 / piece
View lot
6 photos
Manifested
Jellycat Little Pig Stuffed Animal, 7 inches – Farmyard Plush Toy – Classic Children’s Gift 50 units · NWT · Ships parcel
American Wholesale LLC 4.5 (22)
$1,870 $37.40 / piece 83 % of retail
View lot
2 photos
Assortment New
Mattel Hot Wheels Mix (80 Pcs Lot) 80 units · Shelf pulls · Ships parcel
Discount Wholesalers Inc (DWI) 4.2 (13)
$220 $2.75 / piece
Sells in ~49 days on resale
View lot
6 photos
Manifested
Jellycat Clyde Capybara Stuffed Animal, 9.5 inches – Capybara Plush Toy – Classic Children’s Gift 40 units · NWT · Ships parcel
American Wholesale LLC 4.5 (22)
$1,980 $49.50 / piece 65 % of retail
View lot
6 photos
Manifested
Jellycat Smudge Bear Stuffed Animal, Medium 9.5 inches – Teddy Bear Plush Toy – Classic Children’s Gift 50 units · NWT · Ships parcel
American Wholesale LLC 4.5 (22)
$2,200 $44.00 / piece
View lot
6 photos
Manifested
Jellycat Bashful Black and Cream Puppy Stuffed Animal, Medium 12 inches – Dogs and Puppies Plush Toy – Classic Children’s Gift 100 units · NWT · Ships parcel
American Wholesale LLC 4.5 (22)
$3,630 $36.30 / piece
View lot
6 photos
Manifested
Jellycat Bashful Toffee Puppy Stuffed Animal, Medium 12 inches – Dogs and Puppies Plush Toy – Classic Children’s Gift 50 units · NWT · Ships parcel
American Wholesale LLC 4.5 (22)
$1,870 $37.40 / piece
View lot

Jellycat in other categories

Live Jellycat lots from vetted liquidators
6 photos
Manifested In demand
Jellycat Bartholomew Bear with Bathrobe Stuffed Animal, 10 inches – Teddy Bear Plush – Soft & Huggable – Classic Children’s Gift 40 units · NWT · Ships parcel
American Wholesale LLC 4.5 (22)
$2,200 $55.00 / piece
View lot
4 photos
Manifested
Jellycat Smudge Pig – Jellycat Spring Collection 2026 Exclusive 45 units · NWT · Ships parcel
American Wholesale LLC 4.5 (22)
$2,376 $52.80 / piece
View lot
4 photos
Manifested In demand
Jellycat Thimble Turtle – Jellycat Spring Collection 2026 Exclusive 50 units · NWT · Ships parcel
American Wholesale LLC 4.5 (22)
$2,365 $47.30 / piece
View lot
4 photos
Manifested
Jellycat Smudge Cow – Jellycat Spring Collection 2026 Exclusive 45 units · NWT · Ships parcel
American Wholesale LLC 4.5 (22)
$1,386 $30.80 / piece
View lot

Mattel in other categories

Live Mattel lots from vetted liquidators
4 photos
Unmanifested
Collectible Mattel Assorted Polly Pocket Dolls Lot For Parts or Repair Used · Ships parcel
Thrift World
$20
View lot
6 photos
Unmanifested
Collectible Mattel Polly Pocket Pet Care Assorted Parts Lot Used · Ships parcel
Thrift World
$20
View lot
1 photo
Manifested
Barbie Iconic Lotion Pump C/P 12 Mattel 12 units · NWT · Ships parcel
Great Buy Products
$56 $4.65 / piece
View lot

Compare and shop

Other brand pairs and the brand hubs, each with its median sold price.

Jellycat vs

Mattel vs

Brands and lists

About these numbers

FAQ

Jellycat vs Mattel toys — questions buyers ask

Answers come from real Poshmark sales and live Closo lots, not from marketing copy.

Which resells for more, Jellycat or Mattel toys?
Jellycat. Used Jellycat toys sold for a $27 median on Poshmark over the last 12 months, against $15 for Mattel.
Which sells faster?
Jellycat: a median of 18 days from listing to sale, against 33 days for Mattel. 61% of Jellycat listings sold in the period, 18% of Mattel.
Where can I buy Jellycat or Mattel toys wholesale?
Closo Wholesale sells manifested pallets and case packs from vetted U.S. liquidators; the Jellycat and Mattel lots on the market right now are listed on this page.