johnnie-O vs Old Navy shirts: resale price, speed and wholesale lots
johnnie-O shirts resell for more and faster: a $21 median in 25 days, against $10 in 45 days for Old Navy. Used items, Poshmark sales, last 12 months.
Side by side
Same marketplace, same 12 months, used men's shirts only. Green marks the better figure for a reseller.
| johnnie-O | Old Navy | |
|---|---|---|
| Median sold price | $21 | $10 |
| Typical sold price, middle half | $16–$29 | $7–$16 |
| Median time to sell | 25 days | 45 days |
| Sell-through | 41% | 14% |
| Sales, last 30 days vs the 30 before | −20% | +6% |
| Brand hub | johnnie-O shirts | Old Navy shirts |
Sold price is the last listed price of a sold item. A brand pair page opens only when both brands have 300+ used sales in 12 months.
Buy johnnie-O and Old Navy in bulk
Compare and shop
Other brand pairs and the brand hubs, each with its median sold price.
Old Navy vs
- Old Navy vs BYLT Basics$10 vs $18
- Old Navy vs Patagonia$10 vs $22
Brands and lists
- johnnie-O shirts$21 median
- Old Navy shirts$10 median
- All shirts brandshub
About these numbers
Where the numbers come from
Completed Poshmark sales of used men's shirts by each brand over the last 12 months: both brands are read on the same marketplace, the same months and the same condition.
Sell-through is the share of listings that sold in the period. Time to sell is the median number of days from listing to sale. The sales trend compares the last 30 days with the 30 before.
A wholesale price shows only when a live lot of the same condition costs less a piece than the brand's used resale median.
Updated October 19, 2026.
johnnie-O vs Old Navy shirts — questions buyers ask
Answers come from real Poshmark sales and live Closo lots, not from marketing copy.
