Goodwill thrift stores in Sheffield Lake, OH

Goodwill thrift store in Sheffield Lake, OH: 4136 Lake Road. Phone number, map and directions.

1 listed store · ZIP 44054

All Goodwill's locations

1 Goodwill thrift store in Sheffield Lake, plus nearby

GO
Goodwill
Thrift store 4136 Lake Road, Sheffield Lake, OH 44054
440-242-0764Phone
—Website
DirectionsMap
GO
Goodwill CLOSED NOW
4.0 on Google (289 reviews) · as of September 2026
Thrift store 825 Center Rd, Avon, OH 44011 Avon, OH · 5 mi
440-937-3305Phone
goodwill.orgWebsite
DirectionsMap
GO
Goodwill
Thrift store 375 Lear Road, Avon Lake, OH 44012 Avon Lake, OH · 6 mi
440-933-4002Phone
—Website
DirectionsMap
GO
Goodwill
Thrift store 1980 Cooper Foster Park Road, Lorain, OH 44053 Lorain, OH · 7 mi
440-960-5610Phone
—Website
DirectionsMap
GO
Goodwill CLOSED NOW
3.2 on Google (146 reviews) · as of September 2026
Thrift store 1980 Cooper Foster Park Rd West, Lorain, OH 44053 Lorain, OH · 7 mi
440-960-5610Phone
gwlco.orgWebsite
DirectionsMap
GO
Goodwill CLOSED NOW
3.9 on Google (326 reviews) · as of September 2026
Thrift store 502 Abbe Rd N, Elyria, OH 44035 Elyria, OH · 7 mi
440-365-7772Phone
gwlco.orgWebsite
DirectionsMap
GO
Goodwill CLOSED NOW
3.8 on Google (181 reviews) · as of September 2026
Second-hand store 33789 Center Ridge Rd, North Ridgeville, OH 44039 North Ridgeville, OH · 9 mi
440-327-9944Phone
—Website
DirectionsMap
GO
Goodwill CLOSED NOW
3.7 on Google (366 reviews) · as of September 2026
Thrift store 23100 Lorain Road, North Olmsted, OH 44070 North Olmsted, OH · 13 mi
440-777-4422Phone
goodwillgoodskills.orgWebsite
DirectionsMap

Lots

Lots from Ohio suppliers

Shop Ohio lots
3 photos
Assortment
Money Maker Profit Bags (21"x15"x14") — 10 pack 10 units · Ships parcel
Millennial Profit Merch
$55 $5.50 / piece
Sells in ~30 days on resale
View lot
51 photos
Manifested
Women's Apparel Lot - 37 Items 37 units · NWT · Ships parcel
Miami Valley Liquidation
$107 $1,025 retail 90% off
View lot
3 photos
Assortment
Christmas Profit Bags (21"x15"x14") — 5 pack 5 units · Ships parcel
Millennial Profit Merch
$33 $6.60 / piece
Sells in ~30 days on resale
View lot
1 photo
Assortment Trending
10 Hat Mystery Reseller Box 10 units · NWT · Ships parcel
Millennial Profit Merch
$60 $6.05 / piece
Sells in ~52 days on resale
View lot
48 photos
Manifested
Girl's Apparel Lot 2 - 50 Units 50 units · NWT · Ships parcel
Miami Valley Liquidation
$96 $869 retail 89% off
View lot
7 photos
Manifested
BIOACTIVE Liquid Ashwagandha Supplement Drops [Expo 12/29] - 25 Count 25 units · NWT · Ships parcel
Miami Valley Liquidation
$96 $750 retail 87% off
View lot

Goodwill Outlets near Sheffield Lake

Goodwill in Sheffield Lake — questions

Where is the nearest Goodwill Outlet to Sheffield Lake?

The nearest Goodwill Outlet we list is Goodwill Cleveland Outlet and Opportunity Center, 17903 St. Clair Ave., Cleveland, OH — about 28 miles from the Goodwill stores we list in Sheffield Lake. Outlets sell from bins by weight rather than by the item.