Mystery Spot
Mystery Spot, a thrift store at 72 Main Street, Phoenicia, NY 12464. Phone 845-688-7868. Directions and nearby thrift stores on Closo.
- Address
- Verified
- Hours & prices
- Not published yet
- Last checked
- Sep 22, 2026
- Details as of
- September 2026
- Kind
- Thrift store
- Where
- Phoenicia, NY
- Pricing
- Per item, by day
- Sources
- 2
Where the stock comes from
Retailers named by the store; the mix changes with every truckload. Categories are matched to Closo shelves, so the resale number is real.
Resale market
Estimated resale value
$16 median resale · Women's tops
Shelves typical for thrift stores resell for a median $16 (women's tops) on resale marketplaces — most sell between $10 and $28.
Typical for thrift stores — this store has not said what it stocks. U.S. marketplace sold prices per shelf, last 90 days — not a store's own sales. Data through Oct 19, 2026. Resale price guide →
Sold by resellers · Women's tops · Men's shirts · Dining & kitchen · Shoes
Recent online sales of items on these shelves, sold by resellers across the U.S. Examples of what the shelves sell for, not items from this store.
JW Anderson Unisex White Collared Long Sleeve Button-Up Shirt Size M$70MUsedOct 17
Bulwark FR iQ Series Endurance Shirt Mens Medium Khaki Flame Resistan…$22MUsedOct 14
joie Spill Proof ICE CUBE TRAY with SPILL PROOF LID...LOT OF 2 5407$9OSUsedOct 13
UGG Neumel II Chestnut Suede Boots Toddler Size 11 Kids Ankle Boots$1811 Toddler Unisex BootUsedOct 9
Photos and titles belong to the sellers.
Lots near Phoenicia
Lots within 100 mi of Phoenicia
Wholesale lots for sale now from the suppliers nearest to Phoenicia.
Sold near Phoenicia
Recently sold within 100 mi of Phoenicia
What sold from suppliers near Phoenicia, with the last price and the month.
Hours
No hours published yet. Know them? Tell us →
Reviews and questions
Thanks — your post will appear after a quick check.
You have sent several posts in a short time. Please try again in an hour.
Please write at least 40 characters, pick a rating for a review, and check the e-mail address.
Something went wrong on our side. Please try again in a few minutes.
Mystery Spot reports
Reseller reports from visits — prices seen, restock timing, what was in the bins.
Report a change · Data as of Sep 22, 2026
Wholesale lots that ship to Phoenicia
The same stock by the pallet from checked New York suppliers, manifested — payment held until you accept delivery. Free shipping on your first order of $100 or more. US parcel shipping.
Shop New York lots Your store?Own this store? Claim it
Keep prices and restock days current yourself, answer reports, and buy truckloads on Closo with Payment Protection.
Claim this store