Thrift stores in Effingham, Illinois

Thrift stores in Effingham, Illinois: 1502 E Fayette Ave; 908 West Fayette Avenue; +1 more. Hours, phone numbers, map and directions for each.

All with their hours listed.

3 listed · checked Sep 29, 2026

Kind Thrift stores
Hours Any
Restock Any day
Pricing Any
State Illinois
City Effingham
Effingham ×

3 thrift stores in Effingham, plus nearby

At a glance

Thrift stores in Effingham at a glance

Compare the tags at Second Hand Rose, Silk Purse and Goodwill.

3
thrift stores listed
in Effingham · checked Sep 29
$16
U.S. resale median · women's tops
sold prices, last 90 days
1,915
live lots ship from Illinois
updated Oct 17, 2026
Resale pricesWhat thrift finds resell forSold prices for the shelves thrift stores usually carry: women's tops, men's shirts, shoes, dining & kitchen.See resale prices Liquidation lotsShop liquidation lots shipping from Illinois$4.95 median per unit79% of MSRP3 suppliersFree shipping on your first order of $100 or more · US parcel shippingShop Illinois lots

Compare pallet prices shipping to Illinois →

Hours

Thrift stores open today in Effingham

3 list hours for today — latest closing first.

Lots

Lots from Illinois suppliers

Shop Illinois lots →
8 photos
Assortment New
V-ECO Replaceable Brush Head Toothbrush System – Stainless – Item #9627 144 units · Ships parcel
H & J Liquidators and Closeouts, Inc. 3.0 (2)
$134 $0.93 / piece
View lot
8 photos
Manifested
6 pieces – Waterproof Plastic Tablecloth – 140g Thick – 84 x 84 Inches Round – White – Item #9713 8 units · Ships parcel
H & J Liquidators and Closeouts, Inc. 3.0 (2)
$79 $9.91 / piece
View lot
7 photos
Assortment
4 pieces – Waterproof Plastic Tablecloth – 140g Thick – 54 x 108 Inches Rectangle – Assorted – Item #9709 12 units · Ships parcel
H & J Liquidators and Closeouts, Inc. 3.0 (2)
$89 $7.43 / piece
View lot
4 photos
Assortment New
24-Day Surprise Holiday Christmas Squishy Advent Calendar 12 units · Ships parcel
TAGCO - THE AMERICAN GIFT COMPANY
$198 $24 retail
View lot
8 photos
Manifested New
Silky-Soft Satin Sheet Set – 4 Piece — Evergreen / Queen 4 units · Ships parcel
TAGCO - THE AMERICAN GIFT COMPANY
$18 $4.54 / piece
View lot
8 photos
Manifested New
Silky-Soft Satin Sheet Set – 4 Piece — Evergreen / King 4 units · Ships parcel
TAGCO - THE AMERICAN GIFT COMPANY
$20 $4.95 / piece
View lot
8 photos
Assortment In demand
FYM Motorcycles Wheels and Tires Parts Pallet 34 units · Ships parcel or freight from IL
Countryside Closeouts
$924 $27.18 / piece
View lot
How thrift pricing works

Colour tags, rotating discounts

Thrift racks price by tag colour and rotate which colour is discounted, so the day matters more than the rack.

Read the method For owners

Run a store listed here? Claim it

Keep prices and restock days current yourself, answer reports, and buy truckloads on Closo with Payment Protection.

Claim your listing

Thrift and resale stores in Effingham — questions

How many are there in Effingham?

3 listed. Each one gets a page of its own once a second source, its own chain, its own website or a recent map check confirms it.

What do they mostly carry?

mixed.

Which ZIP codes are they in?

All 3 are in ZIP code 62401.

Do they publish opening hours?

All 3 list their hours.

Are any thrift stores in Effingham open 24 hours?

None of the 3 thrift stores we list in Effingham is open 24 hours. The latest any of them closes is 7 PM (2 close then). 1 opens on Sunday. Hours as listed, last checked Sep 29, 2026.

Which cities nearby list thrift stores too?

Shelbyville (24 mi, 1 listed).

Are there any thrift stores in Effingham, Illinois?

Yes — 3 thrift stores are listed in Effingham, each with its address and map on this page.

Is a resale shop the same as a thrift store?

Mostly. Both sell used goods, donated or bought in. Consignment shops, which pay the owner when an item sells, have a list of their own.