Thrift stores in New Hartford, New York: 49 New Hartford Shopping Plaza; 4456 Commercial Dr; +1 more. Hours, phone numbers, map and directions for each.
All with their hours listed.
3 listed · checked Sep 29, 2026
At a glance
Compare the tags at Thrifty Shopper, Mariah's Closet and Recycling in Style.
Hours
3 list hours for today — latest closing first. Open now in New Hartford:
Lots
Thrift racks price by tag colour and rotate which colour is discounted, so the day matters more than the rack.
Read the method For ownersKeep prices and restock days current yourself, answer reports, and buy truckloads on Closo with Payment Protection.
Claim your listing3 listed. Each one gets a page of its own once a second source, its own chain, its own website or a recent map check confirms it.
All 3 are in ZIP code 13413.
All 3 list their hours.
None of the 3 thrift stores we list in New Hartford is open 24 hours. The latest any of them closes is 9 PM. 1 opens on Sunday. Hours as listed, last checked Sep 29, 2026.
Utica (4 mi, 4 listed).
Yes — 3 thrift stores are listed in New Hartford, each with its address and map on this page.
Mostly. Both sell used goods, donated or bought in. Consignment shops, which pay the owner when an item sells, have a list of their own.
We use strictly-necessary cookies to run Closo, and — only with your consent — preferences, analytics, and marketing cookies. See our Cookie Policy.
Tell us what you resell and we put the right lots first — with real resale numbers on every line.