Medieval Collectibles reviews
Checked facts: 23 years online, street address on the site — as of .
Sourcing in person? Thrift stores in Indiana — with addresses and opening hours — are on a page of their own.
- Online since
- Street address
- Found
- Website
- Reachable
- Reviews on Closo
- 0
- Reviews elsewhere
- 15
- Closo orders
- 0
- Reliability score
- 85 / 100
Questions buyers ask about Medieval Collectibles
Four questions, answered from the record: the company's public footprint.
Is Medieval Collectibles legit?
Checked facts: 23 years online, street address on the site — as of Sep 27, 2026. These are facts the registry could check, not an endorsement.
Medieval Collectibles reviews: what buyers say
15 reviews, 2.0 out of 5 on average. None of them comes from a Closo order yet — Closo counts only reviews from a purchase it can see.
Medieval Collectibles second-hand: what they sell
A thrift store on record for vintage clothing. That is what the registry holds about the goods.
Where does Medieval Collectibles ship from?
The registry records Medieval Collectibles at North Richland Creek Drive 401, Princeton, IN — the address on the company's public footprint. Shipping terms are agreed with the supplier; Closo does not quote them here.
- Kind
- Thrift store
- Where
- Princeton, IN
- Categories
- 1
What Medieval Collectibles sells
A thrift store on record for vintage clothing.
What the registry holds about the goods. Facts it can check — address, domain, payment methods — feed the score.
- Website
- Reachable
- Physical address
- Found
- Domain age
- Reviews on Closo
- 0
- Reviews elsewhere
- 15
- Closo orders
- 0
- Reliability score
- 85 / 100
Why this profile scores 85
Every supplier is scored from 0 to 100 on facts we can check ourselves — not on what the company says about itself. The same checks run for everyone, the method is published in full, and no supplier can pay to change a score.
Medieval Collectibles reviews
No Closo reviews yet; 15 reviews on other sites. Closo counts only reviews from a purchase it can see.
Bought from this supplier? Attach any proof of a direct purchase — invoice, payment confirmation, order email — and yours will be the first that counts here: write a review.
Elsewhere 15 · 2.0/5
Item came quickly was good quality but did not fit. Went to exchange it and was told I had to pay to ship it then I would receive store credit and must purchase again and pay shipping a second time. And I still would not know if it was going to fit properly. By the time I would be done with exchange it would cost my twice what outfit would be worth and it may still not fit. Would not buy again!!
The website uses AI in it's advertisements, which makes me kinda distrustful of the pictures of the items nowadays unless I know its old stock.
I'm gonna take my business elsewhere from now on, until or unless they desist using generative image AI (which is known to be built using art without permission from the copyright holder)
do NOT buy from this store. decently fast shipping and quick customer service when I emailed, but extremely expensive for a low-quality and pathetically small mace. when I went to do the return I had to make a paypal account for it, and then pay $16 for a return label. I only got $48 back for a $64 item. not worth it, avoid
Bought a sword cane from here and it's like it came from Temu. The glue from day 1 already broke it seal so it shakes and the sword wasn't even connected to the handle was just laying in the shaft
One of the worst e-commerce experiences I've ever had. I ordered several items two months before a ren fair, and the website said they would arrive in 4-5 weeks because some of them were on backorder. 6 weeks pass and I hear nothing. I go on the website and it says the order is processing. I try to call but it's a Saturday, so I have to wait until the following Monday, meanwhile the Ren Faire is in 8 days. Finally on Monday I call them and just order different stuff that isn't on backorder. It's supposed to arrive Friday, giving me at least one day's buffer to try it all on. Comes Saturday, th
Don't usually do negative reviews but received a damaged item (May 2024). Contacted Medieval collectibles (MC), as their policy says, and was told I have to pay for return shipping of damaged item and pay for the shipping of the replacement item. Ridiculous, so I contacted Paypal (PP) opened a dispute, and they said don't communicate with MC anymore, only PP from now on. That is when MC got ugly. Rude, condescending, arrogant, harassing and lies from that point on. They even asked PP for me to go to a specialist and have the damage of the item assessed lol. It was a $30 statue from China. PP s
Reviews published on other review sites, quoted as they appear there; they are not part of the Closo rating.
Buying from a supplier you don't know yet
This company has no orders on Closo. Pay the way that leaves the money in your reach until the pallet is in your hands.
What a protected order gives you
- Escrow on every orderYour payment sits with Closo and is not paid out while the lot is on its way.
- A manifest on every lotBrand, item, size, condition, quantity and unit MSRP — line by line, and you check the delivery against it.
- 5 business days to checkOpen a dispute inside the window and the money is still held while it is decided.
What no registry can promise
- Never wire money you can't get backA wire is final. A score of 85 is a record of checks, not a guarantee of the deal.
- No return flowLiquidation lots are final-sale purchases. A claim is monetary, per line, and the goods stay with you.
Start a protected deal
- Your money is held until you accept the delivery.
- 0 % commission on the buyer's side.
Own this company?
- Verify a mailbox on the domain and the profile is yours to manage.
- Facts and replies come from you; the score still follows the published method.
Read: Medieval Collectibles Review 2026: Is It Worth Ordering?
Apparel lots live on Closo right now — every one ships with its manifest, and your payment is held until you accept delivery.
Facts first. Then the deal.
23 years online, a street address that checks out, 15 reviews on other sites — and, on a Closo order, your money held until the pallet arrives.
