Sell Through Rate 101: Why 90% of Resellers Fail to Track This Metric

I still have the "Lesson of the Ceramic Clowns" burned into my memory. It was early 2019, and I walked into an estate sale where I found a shelf full of hand-painted ceramic clowns. They were marked at $2 each. I quickly checked eBay active listings and saw people asking $40 for similar ones. My brain did the math: "$38 profit times 20 clowns equals $760." I bought them all.

Six months later, I still had 19 clowns. The one that sold went for $15, and after fees and shipping, I made about $4. Why did I fail? Because I looked at the asking price (Active Listings) but ignored the sell through rate. I didn't realize that while 500 people were trying to sell these clowns, only 5 people a month were actually buying them. That experience taught me that price is vanity, but velocity is sanity. If you don't track how fast items move, you aren't running a business; you're running a storage unit.

 

---

What Is Sell Through Rate? (The Pulse of Your Business)

When people ask what is sell through rate, they are often looking for a complicated economic definition. In the world of reselling—whether on eBay, Poshmark, or Depop—it is simply a measurement of speed. It answers the question: "If I list this item today, how likely is it to sell in the next 90 days?"

The "Inventory Rot" Reality: Most new sellers focus on ROI (Return on Investment). They think, "I buy for $10, sell for $100." But if that $100 sale takes three years to happen, your annual ROI is terrible.Sell through rate measures the liquidity of your cash. High sell-through means you get your $10 back (plus profit) quickly so you can spend it again.

Opinion Statement: I honestly believe that sell through rate is more important than profit margin. I would rather sell ten items at $10 profit each in one week (total $100) than one item at $100 profit that takes six months to move. Volume cures all ills.

The Sell Through Rate Formula (Stop Guessing)

You don't need a degree in calculus to learn how to calculate sell through rate. The sell through rate formula for resellers generally looks at a 90-day window because that is how far back eBay's public data goes.

The Example: Let's say you are looking at a pair of "Nike Air Max 90" shoes.

• Active Listings (Competition): 1,000 pairs currently for sale.

• Sold Listings (Demand): 500 pairs sold in the last 90 days.

What this means: A 50% sell-through rate implies that roughly half of the available inventory sells every 90 days. This is a safe buy.

Here’s where it gets interesting... If you look at "Beanie Babies":

• Active: 50,000

• Sold: 1,000

• STR: 2% This means you have a 98% chance of not selling your item in 3 months. This simple math saves you from bad buys.

How to Calculate Sell Through Rate on eBay (The Manual Way)

If you are standing in a thrift store aisle, you need to know how to check sell through rate on ebay fast. You don't need fancy software; you just need the eBay app.

1. Search for the Item: Type in "Sony VCR Player."

2. Filter by Condition: If yours is used, filter to "Used." (New vs. Used markets are totally different).

3. Check Actives: Look at the number of results. Let's say it says "1,200 results." Write that down (mentally).

4. Check Solds: Go to Filters > Toggle "Sold Items" ON.

5. Compare: Look at the new number. Let's say it says "4,000 results."

The Math: 4,000 Sold / 1,200 Active = 333% Sell Through Rate.Result: Buy it immediately. There are 3x more buyers than sellers.

Honest Failure: In 2022, I bought a box of vintage silk ties. I searched "Vintage Silk Ties" and saw 100,000 sold. I thought, "Wow, huge market!" I failed to check the active listings. There were 2,000,000 active listings. The market was huge, but the supply was infinite. My STR was 5%. I still have 400 ties in a tote bin in my garage.Lesson: Big "Sold" numbers mean nothing if the "Active" numbers are bigger.

What Is a Good Sell Through Rate on eBay?

A common question I see is: what is a good sell through rate on ebay? Is 10% okay? Is 50% unrealistic? Here is my personal benchmark for sourcing in 2026:

• 100% + (The Unicorn): These items sell in days. (e.g., Digital Cameras, Video Games).

• 50% - 99% (The Sweet Spot): These items sell within a month or two. Reliable income.

• 20% - 49% (The Long Tail): These will sell, but you might wait 3-6 months. Only buy if the profit margin is huge ($50+).

• Under 20% (The Danger Zone): Unless it is extremely rare or high value, leave it.

Comparison Table: Sell Through Tiers

Sourcing Smarter with Closo Demand Signals

The manual method works, but it is slow. Scanning 50 items at a Goodwill takes 30 minutes. And sometimes, eBay data is backward-looking. It tells you what did sell, not what is about to sell. I use Closo Demand Signals to bridge this gap.

How Closo helps me predict demand across categories 6 weeks ahead is by analyzing search velocity (what people are typing) rather than just sales history.

• The Scenario: Last October, eBay sales for "Faux Fur Coats" were flat (low STR).

• The Signal: Closo showed a 300% spike in search volume for "Mob Wife Aesthetic" on social/search engines.

• The Action: I bought fur coats before the eBay STR reflected the trend.

• The Result: Two weeks later, the trend hit eBay. My coats sold instantly because I was stocked up while others were reacting to old data.

I use Closo to automate my market research – saves me about 3 hours weekly of guessing trends.

The "Sale Through Rate" Trap: High ASP vs. Speed

We need to discuss the relationship between sell through rate and Average Selling Price (ASP). Sometimes, a low STR is acceptable.

The "High Ticket" Exception: If I find an industrial espresso machine for $50 that sells for $2,000, I don't care if the STR is 5%. I am willing to wait a year for a $1,950 profit. But for a $20 t-shirt? I need a 50%+ STR. I cannot store a $20 shirt for a year; the storage cost eats the profit.

Parenthetical Aside: (I once stored a giant mid-century modern credenza for 14 months. It took up half my garage. When it finally sold for $800, I calculated the "rent" my garage space cost me, and I realized I basically broke even. High STR items like jewelry or video games are infinitely better for storage.)

Why Sell Through Matters for Poshmark and Depop

While we talk about the ebay sell through rate, the concept applies everywhere.

• Poshmark: The "Just In" feed moves fast. If your item doesn't have a high STR, it gets buried in hours.

• Depop: Trends die young. A "Coquette" top has a 200% STR this month and a 10% STR next month. Speed is vital.

Cross-Listing to Artificially Boost STR: If an item has a 10% STR on eBay, maybe it has a 40% STR on Depop. By listing on both, you increase the combined visibility. I use the Closo 100% Free Crosslister to do this.

• The Workflow: List on eBay. Use Closo to push to Depop/Poshmark/Mercari.

• The Math: You now have exposure to 3x the active buyers, effectively tripling your potential sell-through speed without buying better inventory.

How to Calculate Sell-Through Rates for Variations

This is a specific pain point. How do you calculate the rate for a t-shirt that comes in S, M, L, and XL?eBay often groups these.

• The Trick: In the eBay app, click the listing. Click "Sold."

• The Filter: You can usually filter sold listings by size.

• The Reality: Size Medium might have a 100% STR, while Size XXL has a 10% STR.

• The Action: Only buy the Mediums.

Tool Note: Terapeak (eBay's internal research tool) breaks this down visually, showing which variations are moving.

Improving Your Sell Through Rate (Actionable Steps)

So you calculated the sell through rate, bought the item, and it's still sitting. Why? STR is a market average. Your item is an individual instance. To beat the average, you need to be better than the "Active" competition.

1. Price: Are you priced in the top 10%? If you are the most expensive, your personal STR drops.

2. Photos: Is your main photo bright and clear?

3. Keywords: Did you use "Coat" or "Vintage Wool Trench Coat Long Beige"?

4. Promoted Listings: Paying an extra 5% ad fee can force your item to the top, artificially increasing your sell-through speed.

Opinion Statement: I refuse to promote items with less than a 20% STR. Promoting a bad item is like putting lipstick on a pig. It still won't sell. I only promote good items to make them sell faster.

Common Questions I See

People always ask me... Is a 100% sell through rate possible?

Yes, but usually only in "hot" categories like electronics, video games, or viral trends (like Stanley cups in 2024). In clothing, a 100% STR is rare unless you are underpricing your items. If everything sells in 24 hours, you are pricing too low.

Common question I see... How often should I check sell through rates?

Check before you buy. Once you own the item, the market STR matters less than your personal pricing strategy. However,I re-check the STR on my "stale" inventory (items older than 90 days) once a month. If the market STR has dropped, I lower my price to exit the position.

People always ask me... Does the "Sold" filter include "Best Offers"?

On the eBay public search? No, it shows the list price with a strikethrough. It doesn't tell you the actual lower price accepted. This can skew your data. You might think an item sells for $50 (list price) when it really sells for $30 (offer).Use Terapeak for accurate price data, but the standard search is fine for volume (count) data.

Conclusion

Mastering the sell through rate is the graduation ceremony from "hobbyist" to "professional." It removes the emotion from buying. You stop buying things because they are "cute" or "cool" and start buying them because the math says they will sell. It protects your cash flow, saves your storage space, and ensures you actually get paid for your work.

My honest assessment is that you should spend the next week not buying anything. Instead, go to a thrift store and just practice calculating the STR on 50 random items. You will be shocked at how much "trash" is priced like treasure.

If you are ready to stop calculating manually and start predicting trends automatically, use the Closo Seller Hub to arm yourself with better data.

For more on where to list those high-speed items, read our Pages Similar to eBay Guide

And if you want to know which categories will have the highest sell-through next season, check out Trending Products Forecast 2026