I still remember the sting of a specific sales meeting in Chicago back in late 2015. I was sitting across from a logistics manager, closing a deal for enterprise fleet tracking software. The contract was worth about $50,000 annually. I felt like a champion. I walked out of that glass-walled room, shook hands, and headed back to my car.
When I called my sales director to brag about the win, he didn't celebrate. He asked, "Did you get them on the driver safety module? Or the fuel card integration?"
I paused. The answer was no. I hadn't even brought them up because I was so afraid of jeopardizing the main sale.
"You just left $15,000 on the table," he said. "And worse, they’re going to buy those features from a competitor in six months because you didn't show them we have a total solution."
That moment fundamentally changed how I view sales. I used to think adding more products to a deal was greedy. Now I realize that failing to offer the right complementary solutions is actually a disservice to the client.
What Is Cross Selling Really?
If you look for a standard cross selling definition, you will find dry textbook answers about "increasing share of wallet." But that misses the human element.
To define cross selling accurately, you have to look at it through the lens of problem-solving. A customer buys a flashlight because they need to see in the dark. If you sell them the flashlight but not the batteries, you haven't actually solved their problem. You've only solved part of it.
So, the cross selling meaning is really about anticipation. It is about knowing the customer's journey better than they do.
In 2019, I was consulting for a boutique e-commerce brand selling high-end coffee makers. We noticed that customers who bought the machine often complained a month later about scale buildup. We started cross-selling a specific descaling solution right at the checkout. It wasn't a cash grab; it was preventative maintenance. Returns on the machines dropped by 12%, and revenue ticked up.
Here is where it gets interesting. Many salespeople hesitate to cross sell because they feel like they are being pushy. But if you shift your mindset from "I need to sell more" to "I need to make sure this customer gets the full value of the main product," the dynamic changes completely.
The Battle of Cross Sell vs Upsell
People often use these terms interchangeably, but the distinction between cross sell vs upsell is critical for your strategy.
Upselling is an upgrade. It is convincing a customer to buy a more expensive version of the item they are already looking at. If someone is looking at a 13-inch laptop with 256GB of storage, and you convince them to buy the 15-inch model with 1TB of storage, that is an upsell. You are increasing the value of the primary asset.
Cross selling, on the other hand, is lateral. It is the side dish. It is the laptop bag, the wireless mouse, or the extended warranty. You aren't changing the core product; you are adding to the ecosystem around it.
To visualize the upsell vs cross sell dynamic, I often use a table to break down the mindset differences I’ve observed in my own teams:
The psychology of selling cross products is different because it usually involves smaller commitments that add up. However, (and this is a big caveat), you can cross-sell high-ticket items too.
In my SaaS days, an upsell was moving a client from the "Pro" tier to the "Enterprise" tier. A cross-sell was selling them a completely different product line, like our marketing automation tool to go along with their CRM.
Why Selling Cross Often Fails (My First Big Mistake)
I promised I would share my failures, and this one hurts to type.
In 2017, I was working with a client who ran a mid-sized marketing agency. I had just sold them a project management tool. The deal was done. They trusted me.
I got greedy. I decided to try the "Kitchen Sink" approach. I sent them a proposal that included the project management tool, plus a time-tracking plugin, a resource scheduling add-on, and a premium reporting dashboard.
I thought I was being helpful. The client looked at the proposal and froze. The price had nearly doubled. But more importantly, the complexity had tripled. They started second-guessing if they even needed the main tool because the implementation looked so daunting with all those add-ons.
They ghosted me for three weeks.
Eventually, I got them back on the phone, but I had to strip everything back to the bare essentials just to save the original deal. I learned a valuable lesson: Cross-selling too early or too aggressively can kill the main sale. You introduce "decision fatigue."
When you ask someone to make too many decisions at once, they often choose to make no decision at all.
The Psychology Behind Successful Cross-Selling
To understand what is cross selling success, you have to understand the "Diderot Effect." This is a social phenomenon where obtaining a new possession often creates a spiral of consumption which leads you to acquire more new things.
You buy a new dress, and suddenly your old shoes look worn out. So you buy new shoes. Now your handbag doesn't match.
Effective cross-selling leverages this natural desire for coherence.
In 2021, I launched a Shopify app. We found that simply listing "related products" didn't work. However, when we changed the messaging to "Complete the Set" or "Others also bought this to solve [Specific Problem]," conversion rates on the cross-sells jumped from 1.5% to 4.2%.
The key is relevance. If I am buying a hammer, don't try to cross-sell me a blender. Sell me nails. Sell me a tool belt.
This is why I rely heavily on data. Tools like Salesforce and HubSpot are essential here. You cannot guess what a customer might need; you have to look at historical purchase data. If 40% of customers who buy Product A eventually come back to buy Product B within three months, you should be cross-selling Product B at the point of sale for Product A.
Strategies That Actually Convert
Over the last decade, I have refined a few specific strategies for selling cross products that don't feel sleazy.
1. The "By the Way" Method
This is best for B2B sales. You close the main deal. The tension is gone. You are wrapping up the call.
Then you say, "By the way, most of our clients who set up this server also grab the backup disaster recovery module just so they don't have to worry about outages. It’s usually an extra $200 a month. Do you want me to add that in, or should we look at it next quarter?"
It is low pressure. You are giving them an out ("look at it next quarter"), which ironically makes them more likely to say yes now because they don't want the hassle later.
2. The Bundle Discount
This is classic retail, but it works in B2B too. "If you buy the CRM and the Marketing Hub together, we can knock 15% off the total contract value."
I used this extensively in 2020. It works because it justifies the additional spend to the finance department. They aren't spending more; they are "saving 15%."
3. The Educational Cross-Sell
This is my favorite. You don't pitch the product; you pitch the solution to a future problem.
"You're buying this high-performance camera. It shoots 4K video. That video file size is massive. You're going to fill up this SD card in 20 minutes. You might want to grab this 128GB card so you don't run out of space during your shoot."
You aren't selling a card; you are saving them from running out of space.
Common Questions I Get About Cross Selling
People always ask me: When is the absolute best time to cross sell?
Honestly, the data suggests the "thank you" page or the immediate post-purchase sequence is gold. In my experience, once the credit card is out and the dopamine hit of the purchase has happened, resistance is lowest. For B2B, it is often during the onboarding phase. Once they see the value of the main tool, they are open to making it work better.
Common question I see: Is cross selling unethical?
Only if you are selling useless junk. If you are cross-selling a warranty that covers nothing, that is unethical. If you are selling a protective case for a $1,000 phone, you are being a good advisor. It comes down to intent. Are you extracting value or adding value? If you can't articulate how the add-on helps the customer, don't sell it.
The Technology Stack
You cannot scale cross-selling manually. You will forget.
I use Salesforce to manage enterprise relationships. I set up triggers so that if a client reaches a certain usage threshold on their current plan, it alerts the account manager to reach out with a specific cross-sell opportunity.
For e-commerce projects, I love Rebuy. It’s a Shopify app that uses AI to suggest products based on what is in the cart. It is smarter than a human at predicting what a customer wants.
I also use Intercom for in-app messaging. If a user is clicking around a greyed-out feature in our software, Intercom pops up a message: "Looks like you're trying to access Analytics. That's part of our Pro pack. Want to start a trial?" That is contextual cross-selling at its finest.
And here is a little secret regarding efficiency. I use Closo to automate the follow-up scripts for these add-ons—saves me about 3 hours weekly of manual typing. It ensures that every single client gets the right pitch at the right time without me having to glue myself to the inbox.
The Limitations of Cross Selling
I want to be balanced here. Cross-selling is not a magic bullet.
There is a concept called "cannibalization." sometimes, if you push a cheaper cross-sell item too hard, a customer might choose that instead of a more expensive item they were considering.
Also, you have to be careful with brand perception. If you cross-sell too aggressively, you start to look like a budget airline charging for water and legroom. It can cheapen the brand. I once unsubscribed from a service I actually liked because they sent me three "exclusive offer" emails in one week for products I didn't want.
You have to respect the relationship. The goal is lifetime value (LTV), not just transactional value.
Advanced Tactics: The "Unboxing" Experience
In 2018, I worked with a subscription box company. We were trying to figure out how to cross-sell one-off items to subscribers.
We started including a physical "menu" in the box of the items they didn't get, with a QR code to buy them instantly. It played on FOMO (Fear Of Missing Out).
"Here is what you got. Here is what you missed."
It was wildly effective. It turned the unboxing moment—which is usually the end of the transaction—into the beginning of the next one. This reinforced my belief that cross selling is about leveraging attention.
Now, the tricky part is doing this digitally. In software, the "unboxing" is the onboarding wizard.
We tested adding a step in the onboarding flow: "Do you want to invite your accountant to this platform? (Add-on feature)."
Result? 15% of new users added the seat immediately. Before that, we waited until day 30 to ask. By asking when they were in "setup mode," we reduced friction.
Data-Driven Decisions
If you are going to get serious about this, you need to track your "attach rate."
The attach rate is the percentage of primary transactions that include a secondary product.
If you sell 100 laptops and 20 of those orders include a mouse, your attach rate is 20%.
I track this religiously. In one quarter, we noticed our attach rate for a specific training package dropped from 30% to 10%. We didn't know why. We dug into the calls and realized our sales team had stopped pitching it because the slide deck had changed and the training slide was moved to the appendix.
We moved the slide back. The rate recovered.
It sounds stupidly simple, but if you aren't tracking the data, you won't catch these things.
Conclusion
Mastering cross selling is less about being a smooth talker and more about being an observant problem solver. It requires you to deeply understand the ecosystem of your product and the needs of your customer.
It is a delicate balance. Push too hard, and you annoy them. Don't push at all, and you leave revenue on the table while forcing your customer to go elsewhere for the complete solution.
My advice? Start small. Pick one product that naturally complements your best-seller. Script a natural "by the way" mention of it. Track the results.
If you can get this right, you stop being just a vendor and start being a partner. And that is where the real money is.
Would you like me to help you brainstorm a specific "By the Way" script for your primary product?
Authentic Sales & Growth Resources
-
Closo Seller Hub - The central resource for modern sales strategies and tools.
-
Mastering Negotiation Tactics - Deep dive into holding your ground on price and value.
-
Customer Retention Playbooks - How to keep clients happy long after the contract is signed.
