Introduction
The first time I realized Depop wasn’t enough, I was holding a vintage Penn State crewneck I found for $6 at Goodwill in April 2022. I posted it on Depop — solid photos, aesthetic background — and got likes but no bites for almost two weeks. Out of frustration, I cross-listed it to Poshmark and it sold the same day for $52.
And that wasn't a fluke. Same thing happened with a 1990s Carhartt Detroit Jacket in February 2023 — Depop interest, zero conversions, then an instant sale on Grailed for $198. That's when it hit me: if you’re only selling on Depop, you're not building a resale business — you're sitting on inventory hoping the right buyer scrolls by.
So let’s dive into real apps like Depop that actually work, when each shines, my failures, the tools that make this scalable, and why crosslisting changed my reselling game entirely.
Why Depop Sellers Need Multiple Platforms
Depop is incredible for aesthetics — curated, style-first shoppers, Y2K fits, vintage denim, Nike tees, silk tops, and designer-adjacent looks. But here’s where it gets interesting: the market is vibe-driven, not price-driven.
Meaning?
You’ll sell your 90s Levi’s 501s. But your Burberry scarf or Acne Studios beanie? They move faster elsewhere.
Real numbers from my shop:
| Category | Depop Sell-through | Crosslisted Sell-through |
|---|---|---|
| Vintage crewnecks | 3–7 days | 1–4 days |
| Aritzia sweaters | 10–18 days | 5–9 days |
| Nike & Adidas tees | 7–14 days | 3–7 days |
| Designer accessories | 20+ days | 5–10 days |
Opinion: Depop is a strong starter platform, but not a growth platform unless you treat it as a funnel, not a home.
So let’s talk about the best apps like Depop — from someone who has actually used all of them to move real inventory.
Poshmark — Best Depop Alternative for Everyday Apparel
I resisted Poshmark at first. The vibe was different — less curated, more mass market. But in August 2022 I posted a Babaton contour bodysuit that sat on Depop for 11 days. On Poshmark? Sold overnight.
Why it’s good for Depop sellers
-
Fast-moving mall brands (Aritzia, Zara, Lululemon, Free People)
-
Broader buyer base
-
Sellers control presentation
Limitations
-
Sharing listings manually drains hours (I failed with consistency early)
-
Buyer messaging less aesthetic-focused
When I got serious about crosslisting and automated sharing, Poshmark became a machine. These days I use Closo to automate Poshmark relisting + crossposting, which saves me hours weekly — especially after big thrift hauls.
eBay — Best for High-Value & Rare Pieces
Now the tricky part: eBay isn’t pretty. But it moves luxury, archival streetwear, and unique items like nothing else.
Anecdote: In June 2023, I listed a Y2K Dior saddle cardholder on Depop. People loved it — nobody bought. Same listing on eBay? Gone in 48 hours for $148.
When to use eBay
-
Vintage Carhartt, Harley, Nike, Levi’s
-
Designer scarves & accessories
-
Sneakers (non-GOAT era pairs, older Yeezy, GR Jordans)
-
Techwear & rare designer pieces
Honest drawback
The UI feels like taxes sometimes. But the buyers? Serious.
And — eBay lets you add video, which is huge for luxury & condition disclosure.
I crosslist through Closo, so I don’t feel the eBay listing fatigue anymore.
Grailed — Best for Streetwear & Menswear
If your Depop closet leans into:
-
Vintage workwear
-
Archive fashion
-
Streetwear drops
-
Gorpcore fits (Arc’teryx, Salomon, North Face)
Grailed is mandatory.
In September 2023, I moved a Carhartt hooded chore coat on Grailed for $160 after it sat 19 days on Depop. Grailed buyers get it — they're looking for patina, fade, cut, era.
Tip
Optimize tags — Grailed search culture rewards key terms.
Limitation
Women's fashion is improving there but still slower.
Opinion: If you're selling men's vintage + streetwear and not on Grailed, you're losing real money.
Mercari — Underestimated, Fast Turnover Platform
Mercari flies under the radar, but honestly? It's been quietly reliable.
Anecdote: A Babaton cashmere scarf I bought for $12 sold there for $65 in January 2024 with zero negotiating and minimal messaging.
Great for:
-
Cozy basics (Aritzia, Lululemon, Patagonia)
-
Lifestyle gear (bags, beanies, scarves)
-
Budget vintage
Limitation:
Search algo can feel random — consistency beats optimization here.
Vinted — Europe energy, US momentum
When I first tested Vinted in June 2024, I didn’t expect much. Three weeks later, I’d sold:
-
Aritzia Effortless Pants ($78)
-
Adidas Samba OG ($92)
-
Lululemon Scuba hoodie ($68)
All faster than Depop.
Strengths
-
Zero seller fees
-
Fashion-savvy buyers
-
Strong for Y2K, basics, curated wardrobes
Weakness
Still scaling in US. Great upside — but buyer pool still growing.
Comparison Table: Apps Like Depop
| Platform | Best For | Speed | Fees | Aesthetic |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Poshmark | Everyday brands | Fast | Medium | Medium |
| eBay | Luxury + rare | Fast | Low | Low |
| Grailed | Streetwear/menswear | Fast | Low | High niche |
| Mercari | Basics | Medium | Low | Low |
| Vinted | Trendy fashion | Fast | Zero | High |
Sentiment: each has a personality — use that to your advantage.
People always ask me… “Should I crosspost manually or automate?”
I tried manual. Burned out. Missed listings. Lost track.
In October 2023 I finally automated crossposting + delist/relists. Life changing.
Now?
I use Closo to automate crosslisting + relisting — saves me ~3 hours weekly on big haul cycles. And I’d rather spend that time sourcing at Ragstock + local church thrift stores anyway.
Common question I see… “Which platform replaces Depop?”
None replaces it.
They complement it. Depop = discovery culture. The others = liquidity culture.
The real move isn’t switching.
It’s stacking.
Worth Reading
If you want a deeper look at scaling platforms, the Closo Seller Hub has a strong breakdown on expanding resale workflows and marketplace automation, especially the piece on resale cross-platform strategy and another guide on optimizing listing titles for conversions — huge when crosslisting to eBay + Poshmark.
→ Browse those inside Closo Seller Hub: https://closo.co/pages/closo-seller-hub
I have those bookmarked during listing days — keeps my workflow sharp.
Conclusion
Depop built my eye for style and curation. It still matters — especially for aesthetic-first buyers. But the moment I started treating Depop as a starting point instead of the whole strategy, my sell-through changed.
Crosslisting isn’t about abandoning Depop — it's about growing beyond it. Some pieces shine there. Others need eBay intensity, Poshmark accessibility, or Grailed niche energy.
Today I list everywhere and let the buyer choose the platform. I automate most of it through Closo, which saves me hours of repetitive crosslisting + relisting — and honestly makes resale fun again.
If you're serious about scaling beyond cute fits and perfect grid photos, explore these apps like Depop, stack buyers, and treat your closet like a business. The growth is real.
