The Moment I Outgrew Depop
I started selling on Depop in 2020 — back when “Y2K” was just becoming a trend again. My first sale? A vintage Guess tee for $28. I was hooked.
For two years, Depop was my home base. But as my inventory grew to over 250 pieces, cracks started showing.
-
Listing from my phone was painfully slow.
-
Pricing trends moved faster than I could adjust.
-
And worst of all — some great pieces just stopped selling.
That’s when I decided to diversify. I made it my 2023 goal to test every alternative I could — apps like Depop that might fit better at different stages of reselling.
Why You Need More Than One Reselling App
Here’s where it gets interesting.
Depop’s algorithm is style-driven, not volume-driven. If you sell streetwear, vintage, or indie brands, you can thrive. But if you list anything outside that narrow aesthetic — say, Zara basics or techwear — you’re basically invisible.
By expanding to other apps, I found three big wins:
-
Reach new audiences. eBay buyers look for value; Poshmark buyers look for style.
-
Stabilize sales. When one algorithm dips, another peaks.
-
Automate. Crosslisting tools like Closo make it seamless (more on that later).
So, let’s go through what I tested — from the obvious marketplaces to the underrated ones that genuinely surprised me.
1. Poshmark: The Most Social of Them All
If Depop feels like Instagram for sellers, Poshmark is Facebook.
Everything is built around sharing, following, and daily engagement.
My Experience
When I first tried Poshmark in early 2023, I crosslisted 40 of my Depop bestsellers.
At first, nothing. Zero sales for five days.
Then, I learned the sharing rhythm — 3x a day, early morning, lunchtime, and late evening. Suddenly, sales took off.
By month’s end, I’d sold 18 items for a total of $460.
That’s nearly identical to my Depop numbers — but to a totally different audience.
Why It Works
-
Bundles encourage multi-item sales.
-
Offers to Likers convert browsers into buyers.
-
Community engagement actually drives visibility.
Limitations
Manual sharing burns time. I used to spend over an hour daily just clicking “Share.”
That’s when I started using Closo to automate sharing and delisting — saving roughly 3 hours weekly.
2. Mercari: The Generalist Alternative
Mercari is the opposite of Depop — algorithmic, category-driven, and less about “vibe.”
What I Liked
-
Listings go live instantly without social activity.
-
Great for mid-tier fashion, electronics, home goods.
-
Bulk upload and relist tools save time.
My Results
I tested 60 crosslisted items. Within two weeks, I made eight sales worth $230.
Not amazing, but steady.
Honest Downside
Mercari buyers expect deals. Pricing must be competitive, and lower-priced items move faster than high-margin pieces.
Still, it’s one of the few platforms that can move inventory that doesn’t fit Depop’s aesthetic.
3. eBay: The Marketplace for Scale
I avoided eBay for years because it felt too complicated.
But in mid-2023, after hitting a plateau on Depop, I finally gave in.
My Setup
I listed 100 items from my Depop catalog — all manually, just to learn the ropes.
By the third week, I was addicted.
Why It Works
-
Global reach: 130M active buyers.
-
Auctions: perfect for limited or rare items.
-
Analytics: detailed data on views, impressions, and pricing.
My best month ever came from eBay — $1,940 in sales from the same vintage stock that had stagnated elsewhere.
Real Talk
Customer messages and returns can be a pain. But once you understand SEO for titles (“Vintage 90s Champion Reverse Weave Hoodie Large Gray”), it pays off fast.
4. Vinted: The Zero-Fee Option
When Vinted expanded in the U.S., I decided to test it for three months.
What I didn’t expect was how simple it felt — and how low the friction was.
My Results
Out of 70 listings, 22 sold in the first month.
Average selling price: $23.
Net profit margin: higher than any other platform because there are no seller fees.
What Works
-
Great for affordable fashion and basics.
-
Buyer-pays-shipping model keeps math easy.
-
Fresh listings get immediate exposure.
What Doesn’t
Vinted’s interface feels dated, and search filters are limited.
Still, it’s a fantastic secondary marketplace for anyone already using Depop.
5. Grailed: The Premium Niche
If you sell higher-end streetwear, designer, or sneakers, Grailed is worth mastering.
It’s stricter with verification but attracts serious buyers.
My Experience
In early 2024, I moved 25 luxury items from Depop to Grailed.
Sold 10 in 30 days, averaging $110 per item.
That’s double my Depop average.
What I Love
-
Dedicated streetwear audience.
-
Verified listings inspire buyer trust.
-
Negotiation culture feels respectful.
Limitations
Approval delays, category restrictions, and a 9% fee.
But if you’re into curated inventory, it’s one of the strongest apps similar to Depop in spirit — just for a higher price tier.
6. Facebook Marketplace: Fast, Local, and Messy
For quick flips or bulky items, Facebook Marketplace is unbeatable.
It’s not glamorous, but it moves inventory fast.
Real Example
I sold three pairs of Jordan 1s locally in 48 hours — no shipping, no fees.
That’s $480 cash in hand, which would’ve taken weeks on Depop.
What to Watch
-
Respond quickly; buyers lose interest fast.
-
Verify profiles to avoid scams.
-
Avoid shipping large amounts unless you’re experienced.
Use it as a side channel, not your main storefront.
7. Kidizen: The Depop for Parents
This one surprised me. Kidizen specializes in kids’ clothing — but also allows women’s fashion.
Think of it as Depop’s more family-friendly cousin.
My Trial
I uploaded 30 children’s items from a consignment bundle.
Sold 12 within two weeks. The buyer base was kind, responsive, and price-sensitive — in a good way.
If your inventory includes family or lifestyle items, Kidizen fills a gap Depop doesn’t.
Comparison Table: Apps Similar to Depop
| Platform | Best For | Fees | Unique Edge | Limitation |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Poshmark | Fashion resale | 20% | Social & community-based | Manual sharing |
| Mercari | All categories | 13% | Simple & algorithmic | Low buyer loyalty |
| eBay | High volume & vintage | ~13% | SEO + global audience | Complexity |
| Vinted | Basics & fast flips | 0% | Zero fees | Smaller audience |
| Grailed | Streetwear & designer | 9% | Premium buyers | Approval wait |
| Facebook Marketplace | Local items | 0–5% | Quick local turnover | Safety & spam |
| Kidizen | Family clothing | 12% | Niche & kind buyers | Smaller traffic |
Here’s Where It Gets Interesting: Automation Makes It Manageable
When I started crosslisting to five platforms manually, it took me almost 10 hours a week.
Now? Less than 4.
That’s thanks to Closo, which automates:
-
Crosslisting across marketplaces
-
Auto-delisting sold items
-
Price adjustments per platform
-
Inventory sync
I connect Depop, Poshmark, Mercari, and eBay directly.
The system updates every few minutes, preventing double-selling (which once cost me a $90 refund).
I use Closo to automate crosslisting — it saves me about 3 hours weekly, especially during peak season when sales spike.
Honest Failures Along the Way
Not everything worked perfectly.
-
Tradesy (before it shut down) wasted weeks of my time.
-
Vestiaire Collective rejected half my listings for “brand mismatch.”
-
ThredUp paid pennies on the dollar.
Every failure taught me something valuable: the best apps like Depop are the ones that fit your workflow, not the ones that look fancy.
People Always Ask Me: “Which One’s the Best?”
There isn’t one single answer.
But here’s my honest breakdown based on 2024 data:
-
For fastest sales → Poshmark
-
For best profit margin → Vinted
-
For biggest audience → eBay
-
For easiest listing → Mercari
-
For high-end items → Grailed
And if you automate them all together with Closo — that’s where your time ROI explodes.
Common Question: “Won’t Crosslisting Hurt My Accounts?”
I get this a lot.
No, crosslisting doesn’t violate marketplace rules — unless you use fake stock photos or spammy listings.
I’ve been doing it for over a year. Never once had an issue.
What does hurt your accounts?
Inactivity.
Each platform’s algorithm rewards daily logins, edits, or messages.
That’s why automation tools are gold — they keep your stores “alive” even when you’re sourcing inventory.
Lessons from 18 Months of Multi-Platform Reselling
-
Depop is still essential. It builds brand recognition and social proof.
-
Diversify early. Don’t wait until sales dip to branch out.
-
Automation compounds over time. Every saved hour adds up.
-
Each app has a rhythm. Learn it. Adapt. Don’t fight it.
I went from $1,200 to $3,000/month within four months simply by diversifying smartly and tracking results.
Final Thoughts: Depop’s Not Dead — It’s Just One Chapter
Depop is still one of the best resale platforms ever built. But for serious sellers, it’s just the first rung on the ladder.
By testing apps similar to Depop, I found consistency, flexibility, and peace of mind — even when one algorithm tanked.
If you’re hitting a ceiling with Depop, start small: pick one new app, list 20 items, and see what happens.
Within a month, you’ll know if it’s worth scaling.
And when you’re ready to go multi-platform, automate it.
I use Closo for that — it keeps my listings synced, prices updated, and errors minimal.
Because once your system runs itself, reselling stops being a hustle — and starts being a business.
Worth Reading
If you found this useful, check out Best Marketplace Apps (Tested by Sellers) and How Resellers Complete Listing Challenges Faster with Automation for deeper workflow breakdowns.
You can also explore the Closo Seller Hub to connect your Depop, Poshmark, and eBay stores directly.
