Is Reselling on eBay Worth It in 2025?

Is Reselling on eBay Worth It in 2025?

With millions of active buyers worldwide, eBay remains one of the most popular online marketplaces for resellers. But in 2025, when competition is fierce and fees continue to evolve, is it still worth your time to build (or scale) a reselling business on eBay? Let’s break it down with a data-driven analysis, practical tips, and real-world insights.

 

1. The State of eBay in 2025

  • Active Users: eBay continues to serve over 130M buyers globally, though Amazon and niche resale apps (Poshmark, Mercari, Vinted) have taken market share.

  • AI & Automation: In 2025, eBay integrates more AI-powered pricing tools and improved fraud detection, helping legit sellers build trust faster.

  • Shift in Consumer Behavior: Shoppers are increasingly drawn to sustainable, secondhand, and collectible markets—exactly where eBay shines.


2. Pros of Reselling on eBay

  • Huge Buyer Base: eBay’s international reach gives sellers access to a truly global audience.

  • Versatility: Unlike Poshmark (fashion) or StockX (sneakers), eBay supports nearly any category—from collectibles and electronics to auto parts.

  • Auction Format: Sellers can leverage auctions for rare or in-demand items to drive bidding wars.

  • Trust & Longevity: With over two decades of reputation, many buyers still trust eBay over newer platforms.


3. Cons of Reselling on eBay

  • High Fees: eBay’s final value fees (10–15% depending on category) can eat into margins, especially on low-ticket items.

  • Fierce Competition: Saturated categories (clothing, shoes, small electronics) make it difficult for new sellers to stand out.

  • Returns & Buyer Protection: eBay often sides with buyers in disputes, leading to potential losses for sellers.

  • Time-Intensive: Listing, photographing, shipping, and handling returns can become a second job if not automated.


4. How Much Can You Really Make?

  • Side Hustlers: Average sellers working part-time can expect $500–$2,000/month in net profits, depending on product niche.

  • Full-Time Sellers: Established resellers with inventory systems often hit $50K–$100K+ annually. Some niches (luxury goods, auto parts) scale into six figures.

  • Margin Reality: Profit margins often range between 15–35% after accounting for fees, shipping, and sourcing costs.


5. Top Niches That Sell Best in 2025

  1. Collectibles – Trading cards, vintage toys, sports memorabilia.

  2. Electronics – Refurbished smartphones, gaming consoles, vintage tech.

  3. Sneakers & Streetwear – Limited drops still fetch high resale values.

  4. Luxury Goods – Handbags, watches, jewelry (with authentication services).

  5. Auto Parts & Tools – Surprisingly strong category with high repeat buyers.

Tip: Use eBay’s “Completed Listings” filter to analyze what’s actually selling (and at what price).


6. Cost Breakdown: eBay Fees & Overheads

  • Final Value Fees: ~12.9% average across most categories.

  • Payment Processing: Included in eBay fees, but adds to effective rate.

  • Shipping: Buyers often expect free shipping; sellers must factor this in.

  • Store Subscriptions: Basic store at ~$21.95/month helps with lower fees and bulk listing tools.

Example:

  • Item sells for $100.

  • eBay fee (12.9%) = $12.90.

  • Shipping = $6.00.

  • Net payout = $81.10.

  • If you sourced at $40 → Profit = $41.10 (41% margin).


7. Case Study: Side Hustler vs. Full-Time Seller

Emma (Side Hustler)

  • Focus: Thrifted fashion.

  • Listings: 50 active items.

  • Monthly Profit: ~$800.

  • Time Spent: 10 hours/week.

Jason (Full-Time)

  • Focus: Collectibles + refurbished electronics.

  • Listings: 1,200 active items.

  • Monthly Profit: $8,000–$10,000.

  • Time Spent: Full-time operation with software automation + VA support.

Insight: Scale and niche selection determine whether eBay is a pocket-money side hustle or a six-figure business.


8. Tips to Maximize Success on eBay

  • Leverage Tools: Use crosslisters (like Closo), inventory software, and AI pricing assistants.

  • Optimize SEO: eBay search favors titles with brand + keywords + specifics (“Nike Air Jordan 1 Retro High OG Men’s Size 10”).

  • Photos Matter: High-quality images significantly improve click-through and sale likelihood.

  • Offer Free Returns: It may feel risky, but it boosts buyer trust and conversion.

  • Scale Smart: Once profitable, reinvest in bulk sourcing, VA support, and automation.


9. Alternatives and Multi-Platform Strategy

While eBay is powerful, relying only on it is risky. Many sellers cross-list inventory to:

  • Poshmark (fashion-focused, social selling).

  • Mercari (general items, low fees, growing popularity).

  • Facebook Marketplace (local pickups, zero shipping costs).

  • Amazon FBA (retail/wholesale arbitrage at scale).

A multi-platform strategy maximizes exposure and reduces dependency on one marketplace.


10. Final Verdict: Is It Worth It?

Yes—reselling on eBay in 2025 is still worth it, but only if:

  • You choose the right niches (collectibles, electronics, luxury).

  • You manage fees, shipping, and overhead carefully.

  • You leverage automation and possibly cross-list to other platforms.

For hobbyists, it’s a great side hustle with a few hundred extra dollars per month. For serious sellers, with the right systems in place, eBay can still be a six-figure business in 2025.

You may also like

View all