I distinctly remember the moment I decided to open an eCrater store in 2024. I was staring at my eBay invoice for the month, and the number at the bottom made me physically nauseous. I had paid over $1,200 in "Final Value Fees" and "Ad Rates" to sell roughly $8,000 worth of inventory. That is a 15% tax on my hustle. I needed a lifeboat. I had heard rumors of a platform that charged zero listing fees and zero commissions if you brought your own buyers. It sounded like a scam or a ghost town. But I uploaded 50 of my slowest-moving items to test the waters. Three days later, a vintage obscure DVD box set sold for $85. My fee? $0.
That sale was my wake-up call. eCrater isn't just a clunky relic from 2004; it is a tactical asset for modern sellers who are tired of being bled dry by fees. If you search for ecrater reviews, you will find a mixed bag of confused buyers and frustrated hobbyists. But look closer, and you will see a quiet army of merchants using it as a high-margin backchannel.
What Is eCrater Reviews Consensus? (The Business Case)
When analyzing ecrater reviews, you have to separate the "I didn't get my package" complaints from the structural reality of the platform. From a commercial standpoint, eCrater is a hybrid: it is 50% marketplace and 50% web hosting. It allows you to build a standalone store that also feeds into a searchable central hub.
The "Google Shopping" Loophole: This is the single most valuable feature for sellers. eCrater automatically pushes your listings to Google Shopping. On Shopify, you have to pay for apps or manage complex feeds to do this. On eCrater, it happens automatically. Why does this matter? If someone Googles "Replacement Lid for 1998 Crockpot," your eCrater listing pops up right next to eBay. If they click and buy, eCrater takes a small cut (2.9%). If they find your store link directly (from your Instagram or email), eCrater takes 0%.
Opinion Statement: I honestly believe that eCrater’s "ugly" interface is a feature, not a bug. It keeps the overhead low, which keeps the fees at zero. I would rather pay 0% fees on a site that looks like 2005 than 15% fees on a site that looks like 2026.
Is eCrater Legit? The Money Trail
The most common hesitation for new users is: is ecrater legit? We live in an era of Shopify scams and fake storefronts. eCrater is legit, but it is "hands-off."
How the Money Moves:
-
eCrater does not hold your money.
-
When a buyer pays, the funds go directly to your PayPal or Stripe account immediately.
-
This is huge for cash flow.
-
On Amazon, you wait 14 days for a payout.
-
On eCrater, you have the cash instantly to buy more inventory.
Honest Failure: In 2023, I messed up my shipping settings on eCrater. I accidentally set "Worldwide Shipping" to $5 flat rate. A buyer in Australia bought a 10lb heavy metal statue. Shipping cost me $85. The buyer paid $5. Because the money was already in my PayPal, I couldn't just "cancel" easily without refunding fees manually. I ate the loss. Lesson: Double-check your shipping matrices. The platform won't save you from your own math errors.
Analyzing eCrater Reviews Complaints: Buyer Beware?
For a seller, reviews for ecrater look great (low fees). For a buyer, reviews on ecrater often mention "ghost sellers." Because listing is free, some sellers upload items and then forget about their store for five years. A buyer purchases an item, and nobody ships it because the seller abandoned the account in 2019.
How to vet a seller:
-
Check the "Recent Products" widget: If the newest item was added 3 years ago, do not buy.
-
Send a Message First: "Is this in stock?" If they reply, they are alive.
-
PayPal Only: Never use Stripe/Credit Card directly if you are unsure. PayPal offers the easiest dispute resolution if the seller is a ghost.
Parenthetical Aside: (I once bought a rare comic book on eCrater from a seller who hadn't logged in for six months. I didn't check. My money sat in limbo for 30 days until PayPal auto-refunded me. Always check the activity date!)
Sourcing with Closo: Finding High-Margin Inventory
Since eCrater has lower traffic than eBay, you cannot list "commodity" items (like iPhone cases) and expect them to sell. You need "Long Tail" items—things people search for specifically. I use Closo Demand Signals to find this inventory.
How Closo helps me to predict demand across categories 6 weeks ahead is by identifying niche spikes in search traffic.
-
The Anecdote: Closo showed a spike in "Discontinued Ikea Hardware" searches.
-
The Sourcing: I went to the "As-Is" section of Ikea and bought a bag of mixed screws and brackets for $5.
-
The Listing: I sorted them and listed specific replacement parts on eCrater.
-
The Result: Because people were Googling the part number, they landed directly on my eCrater store via Google Shopping. I sold $200 worth of screws in a month with zero marketing spend.
Sourcing with Closo enables me to always sell in demand products that act as magnets for Google traffic, bypassing the need for eCrater's internal marketplace volume.
eCrater USA Reviews vs. The World
If you look at ecrater usa reviews, the experience is generally better than the global site. US sellers tend to be more active. However, eCrater allows international sellers.
The Dropshipping Warning: Many "stores" on eCrater are just fronts for AliExpress dropshippers. If you see a "Tactical Flashlight" for $10 that looks generic, it is coming from China. Commercial Tip: Do not be a dropshipper on eCrater. The margins are too thin, and the "ghost seller" reputation hurts you. Use eCrater for physical inventory you actually own. Buyers on this platform are looking for vintage, used, or specific parts—not cheap plastic gadgets.
What is eCharter? (Don't Get Lost)
I see search traffic for what is echarter constantly. It is a typo. But it matters because it shows that brand awareness for eCrater is low. People hear about it from a friend and spell it wrong. Seller Tip: If you mention your store on a podcast or video, spell it out. "E-C-R-A-T-E-R."
The Fee Structure: Where the Profit Lives
Let's break down the commercial advantage mathematically. Compare selling a $100 item on eBay vs. eCrater.
eBay:
-
Sale Price: $100
-
Final Value Fee (13.25%): -$13.25
-
Promoted Listing (5%): -$5.00
-
Net Profit: $81.75
eCrater (Direct Link):
-
Sale Price: $100
-
Listing Fee: $0
-
Final Value Fee: $0
-
PayPal Fee (2.9% + $0.30): -$3.20
-
Net Profit: $96.80
The Difference: You keep $15.05 more on a single transaction. Multiply that by 100 sales a year. That is $1,500 in your pocket just for changing the URL.
Managing Inventory with Closo 100% Free Crosslister
The strategy I use is "Hub and Spoke." eBay is my Hub (high traffic, high fees). eCrater is my Spoke (low traffic, low fees). I list everything on eBay first to get the fast sale. But I also list it on eCrater using the Closo 100% Free Crosslister.
-
The Workflow: I create the listing on eBay. Closo copies the photos and text to eCrater in seconds.
-
The Pricing Strategy: I price the item 10% lower on eCrater.
-
The Win-Win: If a savvy buyer finds my eCrater store, they get a deal, and I still make more profit than I would have on eBay because of the fee savings.
Is eCrater Legitimate for High-Ticket Items?
Would I sell a $5,000 Rolex on eCrater? No. Why? Lack of Seller Protection. eBay has "Authenticity Guarantee" and seller protections against "Item Not Described" scams. eCrater relies on PayPal. PayPal generally sides with buyers. If a buyer claims "Empty Box," you are in for a fight.
My Rule: I cap my eCrater listings at $300. Anything more expensive goes to eBay or a specialized site like Reverb where the seller protections are robust.
Honest Failure: I sold a $400 camera lens on eCrater in 2022. The buyer claimed it was scratched (it wasn't). They returned a different broken lens. PayPal refunded them. I had no recourse because eCrater doesn't have a "Trust and Safety" team to investigate return fraud. Lesson: High value = High risk on low-fee platforms.
The Store Builder: Branding Your Business
One area where ecrater review threads are positive is the "Customizability." Unlike Amazon/eBay where every listing looks the same, eCrater lets you have a banner, a logo, and categories. It feels like your website.
Commercial Application: Print business cards with your eCrater URL. Put them in every eBay package you ship. "Take 10% off your next order by buying directly from my store: mystore.ecrater.com." You are converting eBay customers (high fee) into direct customers (zero fee). eBay hates this (don't do it via eBay messages), but putting a card in the box is generally considered fair game in the industry.
Reviews for eCrater Support: The Ghost Team
This is the commercial downside. There is no phone number. There is no "Live Chat." If your store glitches, you send a contact form and wait.
Anecdote: I had a glitch where my product images wouldn't upload. I submitted a ticket. Three days later, I got a reply: "Please try resizing your images." It worked, but I lost three days of listing time. Opinion Statement: If you need 24/7 hand-holding, eCrater is not for you. It is a DIY platform. You are the IT department.
Common Questions I See
People always ask me... Why have I never heard of eCrater?
Because they don't advertise. eBay spends millions on TV ads; eCrater spends zero. They rely entirely on organic Google Search traffic. This keeps their costs down, which keeps your fees down. It is a "no-frills" airline approach to e-commerce.
Common question I see... Does eCrater handle sales tax?
Yes, mostly. For US sellers, eCrater has started collecting and remitting Marketplace Facilitator Tax for most states, similar to eBay. However, you should always double-check your specific state's nexus laws in your dashboard to ensure compliance.
People always ask me... Can I import my eBay feedback to eCrater?
Yes! This is a killer feature. In your store settings, there is an "Import Feedback" tool. It pulls your eBay score so your brand new eCrater store doesn't look like a scam with 0 reviews. It instantly gives you credibility.
Conclusion
eCrater reviews often miss the point. They judge it as a shopping mall when it is actually a toolset. For a commercial seller, eCrater is the most profitable "backup generator" you can own. It allows you to capture Google Shopping traffic for free and harvest higher margins on your mid-range inventory. Is it perfect? No. Is it profitable? Absolutely.
My honest assessment is that every serious reseller should have an eCrater store mirroring their eBay inventory. It costs nothing to set up, and even if it only generates 5% of your sales, that is 5% at maximum margin.
If you are ready to find the right products to fill your eCrater store, use the Closo Seller Hub to start your research.
For more on managing payments securely on alternative platforms, read our Facebook Marketplace PayPal Guide
And if you want to know what niche items will be trending in 2026, check out Trending Products Forecast 2026
