Is Ellison & Fitz a Supplier You Should Order From?
Last updated: September 2026
Bottom line: Ellison & Fitz carries a 2.0-star average across 8 reviews on the Closo supplier registry, with 6 of the 8 describing specific, unresolved problems, so the answer for most resellers is not yet.Ellison & Fitz is listed as a thrift store based in Sheridan, Wyoming, at 30 N Gould St Ste N, tagged under vintage-clothing, with a registry entry showing it online since June 2025.
The address and registry longevity are real, verifiable facts. What the review record shows on top of them is the part that should slow down a first order.
What the negative reviews specifically describe
Of the 8 visible reviews, one buyer, Aaron Leckenby, describes paying $7 for shipping. Then being asked for $76 to ship a return — a return-cost structure that, if accurate, makes a refund functionally unavailable. Another reviewer, Beau Maddux, describes the goods as arriving "100% polyester" and "nowhere near advertised fabric," with sizing running small.
Characterizes the operation as a drop-shipment business mailing from China rather than Sheridan. A third reviewer, Chris P. Bacon, states he used a reverse image search and found the same item listed on a wholesale marketplace for €35 including shipping.
These are specific, checkable claims, not vague sentiment — exactly the kind of review detail worth weighing heavily regardless of the overall star average.
Two of the eight reviews are five stars and describe a positive experience: one buyer praised Ellison & Fitz's responsiveness and product quality, and another, describing a pair of pants, called them comfortable and unique enough to buy in every color.
A 2.0-star average built on a mix like this — some clearly satisfied buyers, several describing serious fulfillment and return problems — is not the same risk profile as a supplier with uniformly mediocre reviews; it suggests inconsistent execution rather than a uniformly bad product, though the return-shipping and sourcing complaints deserve particular weight before you commit money.
How Does Ellison & Fitz Stack Up Against Other Sourcing Options?
Bottom line: at a 2.0-star average with 6 of 8 reviews citing unresolved fabric, sizing, or return-shipping problems, Ellison & Fitz currently scores below the baseline most resellers use to justify a repeat sourcing relationship, which is typically a rating above 4.0 with a review count in the dozens or more.Resellers evaluating a thrift-tagged supplier like Ellison & Fitz usually weigh it against three alternatives: a manifested liquidation pallet, a different Closo-registry thrift supplier with a stronger review history; direct sourcing from a known regional thrift chain.
| Sourcing option | Review/trust signal | Reported issue pattern | Return/dispute path |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ellison & Fitz (Closo-listed thrift) | 2.0 stars / 8 reviews, unclaimed, online since Jun 2025 | Misrepresented fabric, wrong sizing, one reviewer's reverse-image-search match on a wholesale marketplace | Disputed: one reviewer reports a $76 return-shipping demand on a $7 original shipping charge |
| Manifested liquidation pallet | Varies by supplier; SKU-level manifest available | Condition variance expected and typically graded upfront | Manifest discrepancy claims usually processed against a documented SKU list |
| Higher-rated Closo thrift supplier (4.5+ stars, 20+ reviews) | Larger review sample, consistent positive pattern | Occasional condition complaints, rarely fulfillment or authenticity disputes | Established return pattern visible in review history |
| Regional thrift chain (in-person) | No platform review trail; reputation is local | Condition visible before purchase | In-person return policy, no shipping dispute risk |
What the reported pattern at Ellison & Fitz actually signals
Two specific claims in the Ellison & Fitz review set point toward a dropshipping pattern rather than a genuine thrift or vintage operation: one reviewer describes the goods as "100% polyester".
💡 This is where Closo's tools connect: Wholesale restocks you from manifested lots, the free Crosslister gets it listed everywhere, Direct gives repeat buyers somewhere to come back to, and Finance shows you the real numbers. Learn more →
"nowhere near advertised fabric," with shipment described as originating from China rather than the Sheridan, Wyoming address on file, and another describes a reverse image search that surfaced the identical product on a wholesale marketplace for roughly €35 including shipping.
If accurate, that combination — a Wyoming-registered thrift listing, goods that ship internationally, and pricing that undercuts a wholesale marketplace equivalent — describes a business model materially different from a chosen thrift or vintage resale operation. One where the "vintage-clothing" registry tag may not reflect what actually ships.
This is the kind of pattern comparison shopping is built to catch: a single review is an anecdote. Two independent reviewers arriving at the same conclusion through different methods (physical inspection versus reverse image search) is a stronger signal.
Compare that to a manifested liquidation pallet, where a buyer knows upfront that goods are being sold as liquidation stock rather than as hand-picked vintage. Prices reflect that positioning transparently.
A pallet seller who sends 200 units of mixed apparel at $1.50 per unit is not claiming those units are hand-selected vintage pieces; the value proposition is honest about what it is. Ellison & Fitz's registry tag versus its reported reality is the more concerning mismatch.
A buyer paying vintage-adjacent thrift pricing for what reviewers describe as dropshipped, mass-produced stock is paying for a positioning the goods may not deliver.
Where a higher-rated alternative changes the calculation
A Closo-registry thrift supplier carrying a 4.5-star average across 25+ reviews represents a fundamentally different risk profile than Ellison & Fitz's 2.0-star, 8-review record. The larger sample size alone reduces the odds that the visible reviews are unrepresentative.
A consistent multi-year positive pattern is harder to fabricate or coincidentally accumulate than eight recent reviews split between enthusiastic praise and serious complaint. For any buyer choosing between Ellison & Fitz and a higher-rated alternative carrying similar inventory categories, the alternative's larger, more consistent review base is the deciding factor, not price alone.
, according to Federal Reserve economic indicators
Quick tangent — I use the Closo Seller Hub to track what is actually moving right now, which saves me about three hours a week of manual search. Worth a peek before your next haul.
What Does the Timeline of Ellison & Fitz Reviews Actually Reveal?
Bottom line: the Ellison & Fitz review timeline runs from December 2025 to August 2026; the two most recent entries — May and August 2026 — split between a serious complaint and a five-star experience, meaning the pattern has not resolved toward either extreme over time.Reading the 8 reviews in chronological order rather than as a flat average changes what conclusions are defensible.
The complaint cluster and what it has in common
Four of the negative reviews describe variations on the same underlying claim: goods that do not match their description. Beau Maddux (June 2026) reports "100% polyester" material and sizing issues on a product advertised with different fabric; Jinx Padlock (December 2025) describes a reverse image search finding "the same items for at least 20% less" elsewhere; Chris P.
Bacon (February 2026) reports finding an identical item on a wholesale marketplace for roughly €35 shipped after using Google Lens;. Giff (December 2025) describes a damaged pair of pants that Ellison & Fitz's support declined to accept as a return, naming a staff member, "Ron M," as unhelpful.
Four independent reviewers, across an eight-month span, converging on overlapping claims — mismatched goods, findable elsewhere for less. Return friction — is a stronger signal than any single review, regardless of how the overall 2.0-star number reads in isolation.
Aaron Leckenby's July 2026 review adds a specific dollar figure to the return-friction pattern: a $7 outbound shipping charge paired with a demanded $76 return-shipping fee.
A return-shipping cost more than ten times the original shipping charge is unusual under standard e-commerce return practices, where return shipping typically runs close to the original outbound cost, and is worth independently confirming with Ellison & Fitz in writing before ordering anything you might need to send back.
Set against that cluster, two reviews — Gary Longtine (August 2026) and derek chase (January 2026) — describe positive, specific experiences: responsive communication. A product praised by name ("fluid pants," bought in every color available). These are not throwaway five-star reviews; they name concrete satisfaction with specific items.
That split, four-plus specific complaints against two specific positive accounts within the same eight-review window, is the core fact a buyer evaluating Ellison & Fitz needs to weigh — not the single 2.0-star average that averages the two groups into one number.
Ellison & Fitz: Frequently Asked Questions
Is Ellison & Fitz a real business?
Ellison & Fitz lists a street address — 30 N Gould St Ste N in Sheridan, Wyoming — on the Closo registry, which is a real, checkable detail rather than a P.O. box or vague claim.
Yet, one reviewer states the actual shipment arrived from China rather than from a Wyoming location, a discrepancy worth confirming directly with Ellison & Fitz. Independently through a business-registration search in Wyoming, before ordering. , according to National Retail Federation research
Why does Ellison & Fitz have such a low star rating?
Ellison & Fitz sits at 2.0 stars across 8 reviews, with 4 reviewers describing overlapping problems: goods not matching the advertised fabric or size, a refused return on a damaged item. A demanded return-shipping fee of $76 against a $7 original shipping charge. Two reviewers, by contrast, describe positive, specific experiences.
The low average reflects a genuine split in outcomes, not a uniformly bad product across all 8 reviews.
What should I check before ordering from Ellison & Fitz?
Confirm the return-shipping cost in writing before you buy, given one reviewer's report of a $76 demand. Reverse-image-search any product photos, since two reviewers independently report finding identical items elsewhere for less.
Ask directly whether goods ship from the Sheridan, WY address or from an overseas fulfillment center, and treat a vague or evasive answer as a reason to skip the order.
How much should a first order with Ellison & Fitz cost?
Given the 2.0-star average and specific unresolved-return complaints, cap any first order at an amount that would not hurt to lose entirely — under $50 is a reasonable ceiling given the review pattern, well below the $150-$300 range that might apply to a higher-rated, unverified thrift supplier. Confirm delivery, fabric, and sizing match the listing before considering a second purchase.
Does Closo protect a payment made to Ellison & Fitz?
Paying through Closo's escrow-style Payment Protection rather than a wire transfer or irreversible payment method gives you recourse if a shipment from Ellison & Fitz does not match its description — the exact scenario multiple reviewers report.
Given the review pattern here specifically, using a payment method with dispute rights is not optional caution, it is the primary protection available to you.
The Decision: What to Do About Ellison & Fitz
Bottom line: with a 2.0-star average, 4 of 8 reviews describing overlapping fabric and return-shipping problems, and one reviewer's $76 return-shipping demand on a $7 charge, Ellison & Fitz currently sits well below the trust threshold most resellers should require before agreeing meaningful sourcing budget.That does not mean walking away entirely is the only rational choice — two reviewers describe genuinely positive, specific experiences with Ellison & Fitz — but it does mean the burden of proof sits heavily on verification before any order beyond a token test purchase.
A concrete next step
If you still want to test Ellison & Fitz despite the review pattern, keep the order under $50, pay through a method with dispute recourse rather than any irreversible transfer. Get the return-shipping policy in writing before you buy — the single detail that, if answered honestly and reasonably, would resolve the most serious complaint in the review set.
If the answer is evasive, or if goods arrive from an unexpected origin, treat that as confirmation of the pattern reviewers already described rather than as bad luck.
For a comparison against Closo-tracked suppliers with stronger track records, the Closo blog base's inventory liquidation section walks through the same address-review-payment framework applied here to Ellison & Fitz, useful if this particular supplier does not clear your bar.
The larger lesson extends past this one listing: a 2.0-star, 8-review supplier with specific, overlapping complaints is a different risk category than an unclaimed profile with thin but positive reviews.
Ellison & Fitz falls into the higher-risk category, and treating every unverified thrift supplier identically — regardless of what the actual review text says — is the mistake that costs resellers the most money. Read the reviews, not just the star count, before any supplier on the registry gets a dollar of your sourcing budget.
Keep going: Closo Seller Hub · Closo Demand Insights · Closo Crosslister.
Restock from manifested lots. List everywhere free. Sell direct to repeat buyers. See your real margins. Closo connects wholesale sourcing, free cross-listing, an owned storefront, and margin tracking into one platform.
Start Free →No credit card required
