What Do Liquidation General LLC (Liquidation Generals) Reviews Actually Say?
Last updated: September 2026
Bottom line: Liquidation General LLC (Liquidation Generals) carries a 3.6-star average across 11 reviews and 79 live lots on Closo Wholesale, a mixed but usable track record that puts this supplier well ahead of the zero-review suppliers buyers usually have to guess on. Unlike a brand-new listing, liquidation general llc (liquidation generals) reviews give an actual read on what happens after checkout — both the wins and the complaints are on the public record, which is a meaningfully different starting point than trusting a badge alone.
The supplier is a Verified Supplier shipping from Missouri, and the catalog leans heavily toward one category: Fan Pack merchandise makes up 58 of the 79 live lots, roughly 73% of the total, with smaller counts in Accessories, Men's and Women's Clothing, General Merchandise, and Underwear & Socks.
That concentration matters for anyone deciding whether this supplier fits their sourcing plan — a reseller without a fan-merchandise sales channel is looking at a supplier whose bulk of inventory isn't a fit, regardless of what the star rating says.
Reading the Reviews Themselves, Not Just the Average
The 3.6 average sits on real variance rather than a cluster of similar experiences. One buyer, Chris Nagel, reported being "extremely happy" with Women's and Plus Size lots, calling the quality excellent and customer service great.
Another, Natasha Klickowski, described a Designer Brands lot that arrived without the promised mix — a single small Calvin Klein piece surrounded by oversized sweatpants — and reported difficulty getting a refund.
That spread is exactly what liquidation general llc (liquidation generals) reviews are for: they let a buyer see that outcomes vary by lot type, not just by supplier, and that unmanifested lots in particular carry more risk than the manifested ones.
A third reviewer, angie garnier, landed in the middle — pleasantly surprised by the variety in a first shipment despite going in expecting "a gamble," which is a fair description of buying any unmanifested lot regardless of which supplier ships it.
How Do the Different Lot Types From This Supplier Compare?
Bottom line: across the four lot categories buyers have actually reported on, Fan Pack and Women's/Plus Size lots draw the strongest feedback, while unmanifested Designer Brands lots carry the highest disappointment risk — a pattern liquidation general llc (liquidation generals) reviews make visible lot type by lot type rather than as one blended score. Treating a 3.6-star average as a single verdict on the whole catalog misses this variance, which matters more than the overall number once you're deciding which specific lot to buy.
| Lot type | Example pricing | Reviewer feedback on record | Manifested? |
|---|---|---|---|
| Fan Pack merchandise (58 of 79 lots) | $357 for 50 units, $7.14/unit | No specific complaint on record; largest share of live inventory | Varies by listing — check each one |
| Women's / Plus Size clothing | Priced per lot, smaller batch sizes | Chris Nagel: "extremely happy," called quality excellent | Reported as consistent with description |
| Unmanifested general mixed lots | Variable, "gamble" pricing model | angie garnier: pleasantly surprised by variety on first order | No — buyer accepts unknown mix |
| Designer Brands lot | Premium pricing tier | Natasha Klickowski: one small Calvin Klein piece, rest oversized sweatpants; refund difficulty reported | Implied manifested, contents disputed by buyer |
💡 Closo Wholesale organizes inventory into curated lots with full transparency on unit count and product mix — so you deploy capital on exactly what you see, not mystery pallets, and can counter-offer if the asking price feels high. Learn more →
Why the Designer Brands Complaint Matters More Than the Star Average Suggests
A "Designer Brands" label sets a specific expectation — buyers reading that name are pricing their bid against name-brand resale values, often $30-$80 per piece on Poshmark or eBay for a genuine Calvin Klein or similar label.
When the actual contents skew toward oversized sweatpants worth $8-$15 resale, the gap between expected and realized margin is large enough to explain a one-star review even inside a supplier with an overall 3.6 average.
This is exactly the kind of risk liquidation general llc (liquidation generals) reviews surface that a simple star count hides: the complaint clusters around a specific labeled category, not the supplier's entire operation.
By contrast, the Fan Pack category — which makes up the bulk of this supplier's live catalog at 73% of listings — carries no similar complaint on the public record.
A $357 lot working out to $7.14 per unit gives a reseller real room to work with if fan merchandise, jerseys, or licensed sports gear sell in their channel; sports and licensed merchandise typically resells in the $15-$40 range depending on team, league, and condition, which leaves meaningful margin even after Poshmark's 20% or eBay's roughly 13% total selling fees.
The practical takeaway is to treat lot-type labeling as its own signal separate from the supplier's overall rating.
A buyer targeting Fan Pack or Women's/Plus Size inventory is drawing from the categories with positive feedback on record; a buyer chasing a "Designer Brands" label specifically should size that order small and verify the manifest line-by-line given the one negative report tied directly to that category.
Unmanifested general lots sit in the middle — inherently a gamble by design, as one reviewer put it, but not one that produced a complaint in the sample of reviews currently visible on the profile.
Category concentration itself is a data point worth weighing on its own. With 58 of 79 lots in Fan Pack merchandise, this supplier's sourcing pipeline is clearly built around licensed sports and fan gear rather than general apparel liquidation.
Resellers evaluating liquidation general llc (liquidation generals) reviews specifically for a fit with their own channel should treat that concentration as the headline fact: a seller without an audience for jerseys, hats, or team merchandise is looking at a supplier whose primary strength doesn't apply to them, independent of the review score.
The remaining categories — Accessories at 7 lots, Men's and Women's Clothing at 3 each, General Merchandise and Underwear & Socks at 2 apiece — are thin enough that any single lot purchase functions more like a spot-check than a category strategy. , according to IRS guidance on inventory valuation
Order sizing should follow the same logic as the category split.
A reseller testing the Fan Pack line, where the feedback is clean and the unit economics ($7.14 landed on the sample lot) leave real margin room, has more grounds for a moderate first order than a reseller testing the Designer Brands line, where the one visible report describes a mismatch serious enough to prompt a refund request.
Splitting a test budget — a larger parcel order in the category with positive signal, a minimal one in the category with a documented complaint — captures the upside without repeating the exact outcome Natasha Klickowski described.
Quick tangent — I use the Closo Demand Insights to track what is actually moving right now, which saves me about three hours a week of manual search. Worth a peek before your next haul.
What Does the Data Behind This 3.6-Star Average Actually Reveal?
Bottom line: an 11-review sample size at a 3.6-star average is large enough to be meaningful but small enough that a single bad experience can move the number nearly a full point, which is exactly the kind of nuance liquidation general llc (liquidation generals) reviews reward reading in full rather than skimming as a headline score. Compare the math: on an 11-review base, one additional 1-star review pulls the average down by roughly 0.3 points, while the same review would move a 100-review average by less than 0.04.
Small samples amplify outliers in both directions, which is why the specific content of each review matters more here than it would for a supplier with hundreds of completed orders.
Reading the actual text rather than the star count changes the picture further. Melissa Hudnall's review describes receiving "100 pcs of low end sweaters" with 94 of 100 items being sweaters and only one differing piece — a complaint about assortment variety rather than fraud or non-delivery.
That's a materially different problem than Natasha Klickowski's account of a Designer Brands lot arriving without the promised name-brand mix. Both lower the average, but they point buyers toward different mitigations: the first suggests requesting a category breakdown before ordering an "assorted" lot, the second suggests extra scrutiny specifically on premium-labeled inventory.
What a 79-Lot Live Catalog Suggests About Order Volume
Maintaining 79 simultaneous live lots, with 58 concentrated in Fan Pack merchandise, implies a sourcing pipeline processing meaningful volume on a recurring basis — this isn't a side operation restocking occasionally.
Industry-wide, liquidation suppliers running that kind of continuous catalog typically source from returns processors, close-out buys, or licensed-goods overstock channels, any of which can produce the kind of lot-to-lot variance seen in these reviews: consistent within a batch, inconsistent between batches sourced at different times or from different upstream lots.
For a buyer weighing this data, the practical read is that liquidation general llc (liquidation generals) reviews support ordering from the categories with clean feedback — Fan Pack and Women's/Plus Size — with more confidence than from unlabeled "assorted" or premium-branded lots, where the two documented complaints both originated.
A $150-$300 test order in the stronger category, paired with realistic expectations for an unmanifested lot elsewhere in the catalog, uses the review data the way it's actually useful: as a guide to where in the catalog to start, not as a single pass/fail verdict on the whole business.
There's also a timing dimension worth factoring in. Reviews accumulate as orders complete and release, which means the 11 on record represent a snapshot rather than the full history of every transaction this supplier has processed.
A buyer checking back in a few months should expect the sample size to grow, and with it, the average to stabilize closer to whatever the supplier's true long-run performance turns out to be — likely landing somewhere between the strongest reports (excellent quality, great service) and the weakest (refund difficulty on a specific premium lot), rather than at either extreme.
, according to U.S. Customs and Border Protection import data
Frequently Asked Questions About This Supplier's Track Record
Is a 3.6-star average good enough to order from?
On an 11-review sample, 3.6 stars reflects real variance rather than uniform mediocrity — the record includes both strongly positive feedback (Chris Nagel calling quality "excellent" on Women's and Plus Size lots) and a specific negative report tied to a Designer Brands lot.
Liquidation general llc (liquidation generals) reviews at this volume reward reading the actual comments over trusting the average alone.
Which lot category has the strongest feedback on record?
Fan Pack merchandise, which makes up 58 of the supplier's 79 live lots (about 73% of the catalog), has no documented complaint in the visible reviews, and a sample lot priced at $357 for 50 units works out to $7.14 per unit landed. Women's and Plus Size clothing also drew a specifically positive report on quality and customer service.
What went wrong in the negative reviews specifically?
Two patterns appear: an "assorted" lot arriving heavily weighted toward one item type (94 of 100 pieces were sweaters in one report), and a Designer Brands lot containing far less name-brand product than the label implied, with the buyer reporting difficulty securing a refund. Neither report describes non-delivery — both describe a mismatch between labeling and contents.
Does Ships from Missouri affect delivery time or cost?
Missouri sits near the geographic center of the continental US, which generally means moderate parcel transit times to both coasts — typically 3-6 business days via standard ground shipping — rather than the longer transit a coastal-to-coastal shipment would require. It doesn't change manifest accuracy, which is the more important factor these reviews actually address.
Should a first order come from this supplier's strongest or weakest category?
Start with the strongest — Fan Pack or Women's/Plus Size — to establish a baseline experience with clean feedback behind it. Save any Designer Brands or unlabeled "assorted" purchase for a smaller, later test once the working relationship and your own grading process are established, given the one documented complaint tied specifically to that labeling.
Where Does This Leave a Buyer Deciding Today?
Bottom line: with a 3.6-star average across 11 reviews, 79 live lots concentrated 73% in Fan Pack merchandise, and both a strongly positive and a clearly negative report on file, liquidation general llc (liquidation generals) reviews support a targeted first order rather than either a blanket recommendation or a pass. The data points toward a specific strategy: order from the category with clean feedback, size any premium-labeled or unmanifested purchase small, and use the $7.14-per-unit Fan Pack example as a baseline for whether the unit economics work in your resale channel before committing further.
The Next Concrete Step
Pull up the live catalog, filter to Fan Pack or Women's/Plus Size listings specifically, and price a $150-$300 test lot against realistic resale comps on Poshmark or eBay before checkout — factoring in the 12-20% marketplace fees that apply regardless of which supplier the inventory came from.
If that math clears a reasonable margin, the existing review record gives more confidence than a zero-review supplier would offer. For more on reading supplier profiles, structuring test orders, and building a diversified sourcing rotation, the Closo blog hub covers sourcing strategy for resellers working across multiple liquidation channels at once.
Keep the Designer Brands and unlabeled assorted categories on a shorter leash until a personal test order confirms the manifest holds up — that's a lesson two separate reviewers already paid for, and there's no reason a new buyer needs to repeat it.
Track the outcome of any order placed here the same way you'd track any other supplier: cost per unit, condition on arrival, and actual sell-through over the following 30 days, so the next decision about this supplier rests on direct experience rather than on liquidation general llc (liquidation generals) reviews alone.
Keep going: Closo Demand Insights · Closo Crosslister · Closo Wholesale.
Source inventory with full transparency. Closo Wholesale shows you the exact unit count and product mix before you buy, with counter-offers on most lots. Free to browse.
Start Free →No credit card required
