Best Selling eBay Items: What I Learned After Listing 500+ Products in 6 Months

Best Selling eBay Items: What I Learned After Listing 500+ Products in 6 Months

When I first started reselling on eBay in January 2024, I had absolutely no idea what I was doing. I bought everything I thought would sell—some vintage mugs, a box of used DVDs, three pairs of sneakers, and a random set of car mats. I spent hours creating listings, optimizing titles, and obsessively refreshing the app…

And then nothing happened. In my first month, I sold just four items, totaling $87. Not exactly life-changing.

But something shifted around April 2024. I decided to stop guessing and start studying. I spent two weeks digging into eBay’s sold listings and analyzing what categories moved fast. That’s how I stumbled into the world of best selling eBay items—and it changed everything.

Quick Answer:
The best selling eBay items are concentrated in a few core categories: sneakers, electronics, collectibles, home & kitchen goods, and select apparel. When I shifted my inventory to match those categories, my monthly sell-through rate jumped from 13% to 51%, and I shaved hours off my workflow by using eBay bulk listing tools and business policies.

Why Knowing the Best Selling eBay Items Actually Matters

Here’s where it gets interesting. Most sellers—including me at the beginning—think eBay is just a “list and hope” platform. But the real advantage of eBay is its data transparency. You can literally see what sells, when it sells, and for how much.

I used to walk into thrift stores with a gut feeling. Now, I walk in with a list—an eBay list—of product categories and average sold prices. My sourcing changed overnight, and so did my results.

This article isn’t theory. It’s what I’ve learned listing 500+ items over six months, testing categories, tracking sell-through rates, and fixing a few painful mistakes along the way.

1. Sneakers & Streetwear — My Top Seller, Hands Down

The first time I listed sneakers seriously was in May 2024, after picking up a few Nike Air Jordan 1s at a local resale event. I listed them on Friday night, and by Saturday morning, three out of five pairs were gone. That’s when I realized I was sitting on a goldmine.

Why this category dominates:

  • Massive daily search volume.

  • eBay authentication increases buyer trust.

  • Predictable pricing thanks to sold comps.

Top performers for me have been:

  • Nike Dunk Low

  • Adidas Samba OG

  • Jordan 1 Mid

  • New Balance 990

  • Yeezy Foam Runner (though slower in late 2024)

But here’s the tricky part. If you’re sloppy with titles or sizing, your listing gets buried. The difference between “Nike Dunk” and “Nike Dunk Low Men’s Size 10 Black White” is thousands of impressions.

I use eBay’s bulk listing tool for sneakers now. I created one clean template and just duplicate it. Listing time dropped from 7 minutes per item to 2.

2. Electronics — High Volume, High Return Risk

My first big flip? A Sony Walkman TPS-L2 I grabbed at a garage sale for $12. It sold for $186 in less than 48 hours. I thought electronics were foolproof. Spoiler: they’re not.

A week later, I had to issue a full refund on a $220 Bose speaker because the buyer “didn’t like the sound.” (Yes, that was the actual reason.)

Still, electronics remain one of the most reliable best selling eBay items for consistent cash flow.

Top-selling electronics I’ve moved:

  • Apple AirPods and iPhones

  • Nintendo Switch and 3DS consoles

  • Bose headphones

  • Vintage Sony Walkmans and cameras

  • GoPro accessories

The big lesson here was about returns. I learned to tighten up my business policies on eBay for electronics—short return windows, clear photos, and exact model numbers in every listing.

And I’m still willing to take the occasional return because this category turns fast.

I use Closo to track pricing trends here. It saves me hours of manual research.

3. Collectibles — Slow Movers, Big Profits

This was a happy accident. In June 2024, I bought a binder of Pokémon cards at a local estate sale for $300. I sold one Charizard for $215 within 12 hours, then slowly moved the rest over two months.

What sells best:

  • Pokémon and Magic: The Gathering cards

  • LEGO sets (especially retired ones)

  • Vintage Hot Wheels

  • Funko Pops (select rare editions)

  • Vinyl records

Now the tricky part: collectibles don’t move fast. But when they sell, they make up for it in margins. My average ROI on collectibles has been 230%, but average days to sell can be 45–90.

I rely heavily on eBay listing tools with pre-filled shipping and return business policies for this category. I’ve learned the hard way that overcomplicating shipping on collectibles leads to unnecessary returns and bad feedback.

4. Home & Kitchen Goods — The Silent Workhorse

I ignored this category at first because it seemed… boring. But after buying 15 air fryers at a liquidation sale in August 2024, and selling them all in less than three weeks, I changed my tune.

This category doesn’t always make headlines, but it moves inventory fast.

Best sellers I’ve flipped:

  • Air fryers (Ninja, Philips)

  • Coffee machines (Keurig, Nespresso, Breville)

  • Smart plugs and lighting kits

  • KitchenAid mixers

  • Thermos flasks and tumblers

Here’s where it gets interesting: shipping can be a pain. My first few air fryer shipments nearly wiped out my margins because I underestimated box and weight costs.

The fix? I built shipping business policies on eBay for home goods specifically, with preset weight ranges and service options. I also use eBay bulk listing tool to list similar appliances in one go.

5. Vintage Clothing — High Reward, High Patience

Vintage clothing was my original niche when I started reselling. And it’s still one of my favorites—when it works.

In September 2024, I found a Harley Davidson bomber jacket for $25 and sold it for $187. Same month, I listed 12 vintage denim jackets. Nine are still sitting in storage.

What works best:

  • Patagonia fleece (90s era)

  • Harley Davidson jackets

  • Levi’s 501 jeans

  • College crewnecks

  • Nike vintage sweatshirts

Here’s the reality: vintage clothing requires patience. But the margins are excellent, and it can build a strong brand identity for your store if done right. I use Closo to track pricing trends and eBay listing tools to duplicate templates quickly.

How Business Policies on eBay Saved Me 6 Hours a Week

In the early days, I set shipping, returns, and payments manually for every listing. It was chaos.

Then, in April, someone in a Facebook reseller group mentioned business policies eBay. I spent one afternoon setting up shipping, return, and payment policies for each category I sell in.

Now, listing sneakers takes me about 90 seconds. Electronics? Maybe two minutes. Collectibles? Under a minute.

The consistency also boosted my seller metrics—fewer shipping errors, faster handling time, and way fewer questions from buyers.

It’s not a sexy strategy. But it’s the backbone of scaling efficiently.

Honest Failure #1: The Book Debacle

I once bought 40 used books because I read “books” were a top seller on eBay. I didn’t look deeper into which books were actually selling.

Result? $200 spent. $0 returned.
They’re still sitting in my garage.

This was my first lesson that “best selling eBay items” isn’t about categories alone. It’s about specific niches inside those categories—like textbooks, collector editions, or trending topics.

Why I Switched to Bulk Listing (And Never Looked Back)

By the time I crossed 300 active listings, manual listing became a full-time job. That’s when I started using the eBay bulk listing tool seriously.

My workflow now:

  1. Draft listings in a spreadsheet.

  2. Upload using the bulk tool.

  3. Apply business policies.

  4. Review errors once instead of 50 times.

This cut my listing time by over 60%. I now list 50–100 items in 90 minutes.

And yes, sometimes the tool breaks. But the time it saves is worth every glitch.

Comparison Table: Manual vs. Bulk Listing

Method Time per 50 Listings Error Rate Best For My Take
Manual Listing 4–5 hours Low One-offs, vintage, unique items Great control but not scalable
eBay Bulk Listing Tool 1.5 hours Medium Sneakers, electronics, appliances Fast, ideal for volume sellers
Bulk + Closo Combo 1 hour Low All categories with comps Best balance between speed and accuracy

Common Question I See: “Should I Only Sell Best Selling Items?”

Short answer? No.

Long answer? It depends on your goals. I still sell niche or personal-interest items sometimes—especially vintage clothing. But best selling eBay items are the foundation of my cash flow.

I treat top categories like my engine and everything else like creative fuel.

Common Question I See: “What’s the Best Way to Organize Listings?”

I’ve tried everything: sticky notes (don’t do this), messy spreadsheets, Notion boards. What actually worked long term was:

  • SKU structure that reflects category

  • eBay listing tools with reusable templates

  • Inventory syncing through Closo

I can now find any item in under 20 seconds. And more importantly, I can scale without losing my mind.

Honest Failure #2: My Bulk Upload Nightmare

In May 2024, I decided to upload 142 listings at once at 2 a.m. (bad idea). I forgot to attach my shipping business policy to the file.

The result:

  • 63 listings with no shipping options

  • 12 buyers overcharged

  • 3 angry messages within 24 hours

I fixed it. But it was a reminder that bulk tools make everything faster—including mistakes. Now I double-check every CSV before hitting upload.

Why Best Selling eBay Items Are a Shortcut to Momentum

When I switched from random listings to focusing on best selling categories, everything changed:

  • My daily sales went from $87 to $312.

  • My average sell-through improved from 13% to 51%.

  • I spent less time listing and more time sourcing.

This isn’t about luck. It’s about alignment—finding where eBay already has strong buyer demand and building efficient listing systems around it.

If you want to scale, this is the easiest (and smartest) lever to pull.

How I Automate Without Losing Control

I’m not a fan of handing my entire store to a bot. But I do automate the repetitive stuff:

  • Closo → pricing research & listing prep

  • eBay bulk listing tool → fast uploads

  • Business policies eBay → consistent shipping rules

  • Terapeak → product research

  • Google Sheets → sourcing tracker

It saves me around 3 hours weekly. And that time goes straight into finding better inventory.

For more context on automation workflows, check out Closo Seller Hub — it’s what I use to tie everything together.

I also recommend my guide on how to find sold items on eBay and how to use eBay affiliate opportunities if you’re looking to diversify your streams.

Final Thoughts: The Best Selling eBay Items Aren’t Hidden

If I could go back to January 2024, I’d skip the mugs and DVDs and jump straight to categories that actually move. The best selling eBay items aren’t a secret. They’re visible in the data.

Focus on:

  • Sneakers

  • Electronics

  • Collectibles

  • Home & kitchen goods

  • Select vintage apparel

Combine that with business policies eBay, the bulk listing tool, and a clean inventory system, and scaling gets a whole lot easier.

I use Closo to automate pricing and streamline listing — it saves me about 3 hours a week and keeps me focused on what matters: sourcing profitable inventory.

You may also like

View all