Goodwill thrift stores in New Windsor, NY

Goodwill runs a charity thrift store in New Windsor, NY. We list 1 Goodwill store here, with each store's address, phone and map.

1 listed store · ZIP 12553

All Goodwill's locations →

1 Goodwill thrift store in New Windsor, plus nearby

GO
Goodwill
Thrift store 374 Windsor Highway, New Windsor, NY 12553
845-569-8265Phone
—Website
DirectionsMap
GO
Goodwill CLOSED NOW
3.5 ★ on Google (338 reviews) · as of September 2026
Thrift store 1488 US-9, Wappingers Falls, NY 12590 Wappingers Falls, NY · 12 mi
845-298-0311Phone
goodwillnynj.orgWebsite
DirectionsMap
GO
Goodwill CLOSED NOW
3.1 ★ on Google (83 reviews) · as of September 2026
Thrift store 88 Dunning Rd, Middletown, NY 10940 Middletown, NY · 17 mi
845-394-2746Phone
goodwillnynj.orgWebsite
DirectionsMap
GO
Goodwill CLOSED NOW
3.7 ★ on Google (177 reviews) · as of September 2026
Thrift store 80 US-6, Baldwin Place, NY 10505 Baldwin Place, NY · 18 mi
914-621-0781Phone
goodwillnynj.orgWebsite
DirectionsMap

Lots

Lots from New York suppliers

Shop New York lots →
8 photos
Unmanifested New
Joan & David High Density Sport Nylon Square Hanging Toiletry Organizer Bag — 367-BLACK NWT · Ships parcel
Magid
$53
View lot
8 photos
Unmanifested
Joan & David The Lainey Sport Nylon Drop Bottom Duffel Bag — 619-GREEN GABLES Ships parcel
Magid
$71
View lot
1 photo
Manifested New
Ribbon Detail Glitter Bangle Bracelet Set 34 units · NWT · Ships parcel
US Jewelry House
$63 $1.86 / piece
Sells in ~116 days on resale
View lot
4 photos
Assortment New
Quince Women's Intimates Bulk Clothing 50 units · Customer returns · Ships parcel
Boutique by the Box
$372 $7.43 / piece
View lot
1 photo
Manifested New
Stainless Steel Curb Chain Anklet — Gold 19 units · NWT · Ships parcel
US Jewelry House
$65 $3.41 / piece
Sells in ~55 days on resale
View lot
8 photos
Manifested New
Amazon Influencer Favorites Swimwear Women’s New Wholesale · SKU AMAZON-100 100 units · NWT · Ships parcel
Boutique by the Box
$124 $1.24 / piece
Sells in ~63 days on resale
View lot
7 photos
Assortment Trending
Tiktok Viral Athleisure New Women's Clothing Wholesale 40 units · NWT · Ships parcel
Boutique by the Box
$297 $7.43 / piece
View lot
1 photo
Manifested New
Stainless Steel Herringbone Chain Anklet — Gold 17 units · NWT · Ships parcel
US Jewelry House
$63 $3.72 / piece
Sells in ~55 days on resale
View lot