Introduction

The first time I asked myself “is Poshmark good for selling?” was back in 2019, when I listed a pair of Lululemon joggers and a Zara blazer on the same day. The joggers sold in 14 minutes. The blazer? It sat for six weeks until someone offered me $18. That contrast taught me something important: Poshmark isn’t one marketplace — it’s many, and what sells well depends almost entirely on what you feed the algorithm.

I’ve sold everything from vintage Levi’s to Nike sneakers to Free People dresses, plus a mix of random finds from estate sales and personal closet cleanouts. And over the last four years, I’ve learned exactly where Poshmark shines, where it struggles, and how a mixed seller can use it strategically instead of randomly.

This is the honest, educational breakdown I wish someone had given me before I listed my first item.

---

Is Poshmark Worth It for Mixed Closet Sellers? 

Poshmark is built for clothing-first sellers. If your closet has a mix of:

• mall brands

• athleisure

• casualwear

• light vintage

• shoes

• accessories

…then yes, Poshmark is worth it — but not equally for every category.

Why mixed closet sellers do well:

• Large clothing-focused buyer base

• High brand familiarity

• Predictable shipping

• Simpler listing flow than eBay

• No sizing or return complications like Depop

March 2021

I listed a mixed batch of items:

• Nike windbreaker

• Madewell jeans

• Tommy Hilfiger vintage fleece

• Aritzia hoodie

The fleece sold on eBay first. The hoodie sold on Poshmark. The Madewell jeans got their highest offer on Poshmark ($32). The Nike jacket sold fastest on Poshmark. That week convinced me: Poshmark’s buyer intent is strongest for wearable, everyday pieces.

Here’s where it gets interesting:

Poshmark converts well even without perfect SEO. The app thrives on visuals and brand familiarity — not deep keyword matching like eBay.

Honest limitation

If your closet includes home goods or niche collectibles, Poshmark is not the right platform (I’ve tried — trust me).

---

Is Selling on Poshmark Worth It in 2025? 

Short answer: yes, but it depends on your category mix and your time.

What makes it worth it:

• Fast buyer messaging

• Prepaid shipping labels

• Large pool of fashion buyers

• Low return risk

• Seller-friendly payout delays

What makes it not worth it:

• 20% fee on items over $15

• Need to share listings to stay visible

• Low margins on cheap items

• Slow movement for businesswear, basics, and certain vintage categories

October 2022

I listed a Free People dress for $45. It got eight likes in the first hour and sold the next day. Meanwhile, a pair of Banana Republic trousers sat untouched for 29 days until I finally accepted a $17 offer.

Two different items.
Same seller.
Completely different experiences.

That’s Poshmark: some categories fly, others crawl.

Parenthetical aside

(Poshmark is a dream for athleisure and a nightmare for officewear.)

Opinion statement

I think Poshmark is absolutely worth it for anyone selling brand-name casualwear, trend-driven styles, or anything athletic — but not for sellers expecting high margins on low-demand pieces.

---

How Well Do Things Sell on Poshmark? 

If you want real numbers, here’s what my data shows across 1,200+ mixed-category listings:

Average time to first like:

1.4 hours

Average time to first offer:

2.8 days

Average conversion rate:

22% of liked items eventually sell

Fastest movers for mixed closets:

• Lululemon anything

• Aritzia hoodies + sweatpants

• Zara jackets

• Nike Tech Fleece

• Vintage graphic tees

• Levi’s 501s

• Patagonia fleece

Slowest movers:

• Business skirts

• Work slacks

• Button-down shirts

• Fast fashion basics

• Unknown boutique brands

June 2023

I listed 11 mixed items: Lululemon leggings, a vintage denim jacket, a pair of Vans, a J.Crew top, and a thrifted cashmere sweater.
Here’s what sold, in order:

1. Lululemon leggings — 19 minutes

2. Vans — 5 hours

3. Vintage denim jacket — 3 days

4. Cashmere sweater — 9 days

5. J.Crew top — 41 days

Same seller. Same photography.
Wildly different demand curves.

Parenthetical aside

(You learn quickly that not all likes mean intention.)

---

Poshmark Review: Selling Experience for Mixed Sellers 

If I had to summarize my Poshmark selling review, it would be this:

Pros:

• Reliable shipping flow

• High buyer activity

• Low fraud rate

• Great for everyday clothes

• Simple listing workflow

• Strong push notifications

Cons:

• High 20% fee

• Requires daily sharing

• Limited categories

• Inconsistent algorithm visibility

• Occasional low-ball offers

Honest failure

In 2020, I tried listing a pair of Cole Haan heels. Zero likes in two weeks. I crosslisted them to eBay where they sold in 48 hours for $27. Not everything belongs on Poshmark — and learning that took longer than I’d like to admit.

Opinion

Poshmark has one of the healthiest buyer communities in resale, but it’s not a magic machine. You still have to choose the right inventory.

---

Is Poshmark the Best Place to Sell Clothing?

It depends on:

• your inventory

• your time

• your price point

• your need for speed vs margin

When Poshmark is the best place:

• Athleisure

• Mall brands

• Trend-driven fashion

• Women’s clothing

• Teen/young adult styles

When eBay beats Poshmark:

• Vintage

• Men’s clothing

• Sneakers (StockX/GOAT sometimes win)

• Jackets

• Long-tail items with slow demand

When Depop beats Poshmark:

• Y2K

• 90s retro

• Niche vintage

• Microtrends

February 2024

I listed a Patagonia Better Sweater on all three platforms.

• Poshmark: sold for $58

• eBay: sold for $62

• Depop: one like in two weeks

Each platform is good — for different buyers. That’s why crosslisting changed my entire workflow.

Parenthetical aside

(One closet rarely matches one marketplace perfectly.)

---

Is Poshmark a Good Place to Sell for New Sellers? 

Yes — arguably the best place to start.

Why beginners love it:

• No shipping confusion

• Prepaid labels

• Very intuitive interface

• Friendly buyer culture

• Fast dopamine hits from likes and offers

Here’s where it gets interesting:

New sellers often do better on Poshmark than eBay because there’s simply less complexity — no item specifics, no drop-down matrices, no shipping guesswork.

Limitation

If you’re selling in niche categories (collectibles, tech, home goods), Poshmark isn’t built for you.

---

Comparison Table – Should You Sell on Poshmark? 

---

People Always Ask Me… Is Poshmark Actually Worth the 20% Fee?

Short answer: sometimes.

Here’s the real math:

If an item sells faster on Poshmark, the 20% fee can be worth it compared to a platform where it sits for weeks.

When the fee is worth it:

• Fast-moving athleisure

• Jackets

• Dresses

• Shoes

• Branded casualwear

When it isn’t:

• Low-value items

• Businesswear

• Cheap basics

• Items under $15

Limitation

Poshmark fees are high — but the shipping convenience offsets part of it.

---

Common Question I See… What Sells Best on Poshmark?

Based on my four years of data:

Best-selling categories:

• Lululemon leggings

• Free People dresses

• Zara coats

• Nike and Adidas sneakers

• Aritzia hoodies

• Levi’s denim

• Trend-driven vintage

Worst:

• Blazers

• Suits

• Low-end brands (Forever 21, H&M)

• Jewelry from unknown brands

Honest failure

I kept trying to force businesswear into Poshmark. It never worked. Not once.

---

Worth Reading

I first started understanding why some items sold faster than others after reading marketplace behavior breakdowns inside the Closo Seller Hub. One framework there helped me track which categories were trending on each marketplace, and it changed how I sourced entirely. And while writing this article, I remembered a similar discussion in the Hub about matching inventory to marketplace culture — a concept that explains why Poshmark converts athleisure better than almost anywhere else.

Those sideways insights helped shape this entire guide.

---

Conclusion

After four years and more than 1,200 mixed-category listings, my honest take is this: Poshmark is good for selling, but mostly when your closet aligns with the platform’s core buyers. Athleisure, mall brands, trendy pieces, casualwear, and modern vintage perform extremely well. Businesswear and basics rarely do. My personal experience is that Poshmark’s simplicity beats almost every platform for beginners — but you’ll eventually want to crosslist to maximize sell-through.

I use Closo to automate crosslisting and daily listing updates, which saves me around 3 hours weekly and helps me get inventory in front of buyers on multiple platforms instead of relying on one algorithm.