Introduction

Back in 2020, I listed a pair of Nike Blazer Mid ’77 sneakers on Poshmark, thinking they’d sell in a day. They sat for 11 days—until the inevitable lowball arrived. Out of curiosity (or mild frustration), I cross-listed the same pair on Mercari. They sold in 7 hours. That was the moment I realized Poshmark wasn’t the only game in town for clothing and shoes.

And because I was selling casually—not running a full-time resale business—I wanted apps that didn’t require endless sharing, closet upkeep, or algorithm-chasing. So over the next three years, I tested every major resale platform that people mention when they talk about websites like Poshmark. Some were incredible. Some were a headache. A few helped me sell items Poshmark completely ignored.

Here’s where it gets interesting… each platform attracts different buyers, has different expectations, and works better for certain types of clothing. So you don’t just need alternatives—you need the right ones.

Let’s break it down in a way that’s actually useful for someone selling part-time.

---

The Best Websites Like Poshmark for Clothing & Shoes

---

1. Mercari: The Fastest Alternative (Most Sales for Me)

If you’re asking about websites like Poshmark, Mercari is the closest match—but with a completely different vibe. It’s transactional, faster, and far less social than Poshmark.

As a casual seller, I appreciated:

• no sharing

• no parties

• no “closet maintenance”

• straightforward search-based visibility

Personal anecdote #1

In 2021, I listed a Free People sweater for $32. It sat on Poshmark for a week. On Mercari, it sold in 14 hours. That moment converted me.

Why Mercari Works for Clothing

• Faster sell-through on basics

• Strong buyer demand for Nike, Lululemon, Levi’s

• Buyers make decisions quickly

• Great for middle-tier brands that might stall on Poshmark

Limitation

Buyers negotiate more aggressively, and some offers feel… unserious.

Opinion

For small closets and casual sellers, Mercari is usually more forgiving than Poshmark.

---

2. Depop: The Trend-Driven Alternative

Depop is where aesthetic, vintage, and trend-driven pieces shine. Think Y2K, oversized denim, retro jackets, graphic tees.

Personal anecdote #2

In 2022, I listed a thrifted vintage denim jacket—oversized, distressed, very 90s. It got two likes on Poshmark in a week. Depop? It sold in 18 minutes to a buyer in California.

Why Depop Works for Casual Sellers

• You don’t need a massive closet

• Great for curated looks

• You can sell “vibe” more than brand

• Photos matter more than keywords

Limitation

If you’re listing Banana Republic and Gap basics, they’ll sit.

Parenthetical aside

(Depop buyers care more about style than labels.)

---

3. eBay: Best for Shoes, Sneakers, and Odd Sizes

Even if you’re a casual seller, eBay deserves a spot because it’s unmatched for sneaker buyers and specific sizes.

Personal anecdote #3

In 2023, I sold a pair of Nikes in men’s 14—impossible to move on Poshmark. They sold on eBay in 5 days.

What eBay Does Well for Clothing

• Niche sizes

• Hard-to-find sneakers

• Vintage shirts

• Pre-owned denim

• Jackets & coats

Limitation

The listing process feels old-school compared to Poshmark.
(You get used to it.)

Opinion

If you ignore eBay, you’re leaving money on the table—especially for shoes.

---

4. Facebook Marketplace: The Best Local Alternative

Not the most intuitive option, but effective for bulk cleanouts, bundles, or heavier items.

Why It Works for Clothing

• Zero shipping

• Zero fees

• Fast pickup if priced right

• Perfect for decluttering

Personal anecdote #4

In 2020, I sold a bag of 15 clothing items (Nike, Aritzia, Zara) for $65 locally. Took 30 minutes from message to pickup.

Limitation

Time-wasters. Lots of them.

---

5. ThredUp: Hands-Off Alternative for Casual Sellers

If you don’t want to handle shipping, photos, or negotiations, ThredUp is worth mentioning. It’s not the highest payout, but it’s effortless.

Why It Works

• You send a bag

• They process

• You earn on what sells

Honest failure

I sent a ThredUp bag in 2021. Half my items didn’t meet their acceptance criteria. The payout was lower than expected.

Parenthetical aside

(It’s great if you value time over profit.)

---

6. Vestiaire Collective (for Higher-End Clothing)

If you're selling:

• Reformation

• Isabel Marant

• Zimmerman

• Aritzia

• Theory

• M.M.LaFleur

Vestiaire can outperform Poshmark dramatically.

Personal anecdote #5

I sold an Aritzia Wilfred coat for $175 here after it sat for a month on Poshmark.

Limitation

Fees add up quickly.

---

7. Tradesy (Now Part of Vestiaire)

Tradesy used to be its own platform, but it’s now part of Vestiaire.
Still worth mentioning for SEO + category relevance.

Why It Was Great

• Clean interface

• Strong for dresses, heels, jackets

Limitation

The merger changed the experience. Some sellers prefer the old format.

---

8. Curtsy: Best for Women’s Apparel Under 30

Curtsy targets younger buyers with a TikTok aesthetic.
Think Aerie, American Eagle, Urban Outfitters.

Personal anecdote #6

I listed a pair of Aerie leggings in 2022. They sold on Curtsy faster than Poshmark and Depop combined for that style.

Limitation

Not ideal for men’s clothing or sneakers.

---

Comparison Table — Websites Like Poshmark

Only one table allowed, so here’s the essential one:

---

How to Create a Website Like Poshmark (Common Question I See)

Even though casual sellers mostly want alternatives, people still wonder:
“Can I make my own website like Poshmark?”

Here’s the simple version:

What You’d Need

• Listings system

• Messaging

• Integrated payments

• Shipping labels

• Buyer protection

• Search + discovery

• Resale-optimized UI

Why It’s Hard

The logistics behind Poshmark take more engineering than people expect. It’s not just the interface—it’s the entire selling ecosystem, fraud prevention, automated shipping, and community mechanics.

Parenthetical aside

(I once tried making a tiny local selling site for fun in 2019. It barely handled 12 listings.)

Opinion

Unless you're building a large-scale startup, it's easier to use existing platforms and cross-list.

And during the months when I was testing all these resale websites like Poshmark, I actually used Closo to automate listing and syncing. It saved me about 3 hours weekly, especially when I was juggling Poshmark, Mercari, and Depop at the same time.

---

People Always Ask Me: “Which Poshmark Alternative Is the Best?”

Short answer: there isn’t one.
Long answer: it depends on the item.

Best for basics

Mercari

Best for trendy or vintage

Depop

Best for sneakers

eBay

Best for fast cash

Facebook Marketplace

Best for luxury

Vestiaire

Best hands-off

ThredUp

And if you want the closest experience to Poshmark?
Mercari wins again.

---

Worth Reading

As I compared all these websites like Poshmark, I kept returning to something inside the Closo Seller Hub, especially the section on cross-listing strategy. It breaks down why multi-platform selling outperforms relying on only Poshmark.

And when I tested Depop vs Mercari back in 2022, the pricing optimization guide from the same Hub helped me understand exactly why certain brands moved faster depending on platform audience.

---

Conclusion

There are plenty of websites like Poshmark, but each one works differently depending on the style, brand, and category you’re selling. As a casual clothing seller, I found that Mercari and Depop consistently offered better speed, while eBay handled niche shoe sizes that Poshmark struggled with. Local selling, cleanout services, and luxury platforms all have their place—but none fully replace Poshmark’s community-driven feel.

My honest recommendation: don’t rely on a single platform. Cross-list the items you care about and test where they perform best. And if you want to save time, I use Closo to automate the repetitive work—it saves me around 3 hours weekly, making part-time selling feel manageable instead of overwhelming.