Maybelline New York resale prices & live listings
Wholesale lots, live reseller listings and real sold prices for Maybelline New York, in one place.
Source it wholesale
Maybelline New York by the lot, next to what it resells for
Cost per piece against what each lot's own goods resell for, same type and condition, last 12 months. Before fees and shipping.
What Maybelline New York makeup sells for
Maybelline New York makeup sells for a median $6 used and $12 new with tags on Poshmark, and $16 on eBay.
Based on 38 sales we tracked on Poshmark and 106 on eBay · Updated Sep 29, 2026 · Data as of Sep 30, 2026 · How we price →
Maybelline New York makeup worth, a piece
Medians of completed sales, the retail price of new listings and the lowest live wholesale price a piece on Closo — each named by where it was measured.
New
Pre-owned or any condition
| Where | Condition | Price | Range | Sample | As of |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| New | |||||
| Poshmark | New with tags, women’s | $12 | $8–$32 | 33 tracked, last 12 months | Sep 30 |
| Pre-owned or any condition | |||||
| Poshmark | Any condition | $12 | $7–$32 | 38 tracked, last 12 months | Sep 30 |
| Poshmark | Used | $6 | $5–$15 | 5 tracked, last 12 months | Sep 30 |
| eBay | Not stated | $16 +12 % | $13–$23 | 106 tracked since May ’26 | Sep 30 |
Changes compare the last 90 days with the 90 before.
When Maybelline New York makeup move
Maybelline New York makeup sells in autumn and winter and spring: Oct, Feb and Mar carried 50 % of the year’s sales, with the peak of 10 tracked in Mar ’26.
The last 30 days ran 200 % above the 30 before them: 3 tracked against 1.
Listed vs sold · Poshmark
Maybelline New York market
Asking prices are listings up for under 90 days; sold prices cover the last 12 months.
Poshmark
Buyer's market · 26 months of supplyAsking $6–$18
Poshmark listings as of Sep 30, 2026
For resellersPrice to sell: on Poshmark, Maybelline New York sells for about 109 % of today’s asking price — list near $11–$12 to move it.
Compared with
Women › Makeup, same 12 months: the category as a whole, and the two brands whose sold prices overlap Maybelline New York’s band.
Category median · all brands
Sells in 91 days, 41 % sell-through.
Holler & Glow makeup
Sells in 4 days, 98 % sell-through.
Lavaa Beauty makeup
Sells in 0 days, 97 % sell-through.
Recently sold
4 newest Maybelline New York makeup sales. Titles as the sellers wrote them, trimmed.
1-Maybelline New York Ultra Liner 302 Dark Brown Eyeliner New Sealed$40StandardUsedAug 22
2 Pack Maybelline Expert Eye Wear Brow & Eye Pencil #101 Velvet Black…$13OSUsedAug 22
Maybelline Colossal Bubble Mascara Womens 2-Pack 801 Very Black Washa…$14OSUsedAug 7
Maybelline Dream Matte Mousse Foundation COCOA 3 Dark .64 oz 1 PACK-…$32OSUsedJul 23
Photos and titles belong to the sellers who listed them on Poshmark.
Related by sales
Women › Makeup brands whose sold prices overlap $7–$32, by sell-through. Each card opens the brand’s Closo hub.
Buying Maybelline New York makeup in bulk?
24 wholesale lots carry Maybelline New York. Escrow-protected checkout.
Maybelline New York listed by Closo resellers
Live items in resellers' own Closo shops — buying here goes straight to the seller, with Closo buyer protection.
6 photos
View in Shawna’s shop
View in High’s shop
View in High’s shop
View in High’s shop
View in High’s shop
2 photos
View in Tomasz’s shop
3 photos
View in Tomasz’s shop
View in High’s shop
View in High’s shop
2 photos
View in High’s shop
View in High’s shop
View in High’s shop
View in High’s shop
View in High’s shop
5 photos
View in Sam’s shop
View in High’s shop
View in High’s shop
View in WIDELENE’s shopSource Maybelline New York for your store
- Pallets and case packs from vetted U.S. liquidators
- Escrow until you accept · five business days to check the manifest
- Freight quoted to your ZIP · first order backed by Closo
Sell your Maybelline New York with Closo
- List once — eBay, Poshmark, Depop, Vinted and Mercari, kept in sync
- Your own Closo shop · 0% commission, buyer protection included
- Resale comps on every listing · what it actually sells for, before you price it
Compare resale prices nearby
The brands and categories closest to Maybelline New York, each with its median sold price, its sales, its live listings or its monthly searches.
Similar brands by sales
- Jones Road$17
- Origins$18
- Tough2sweet$8
- Rhode$34
- Chic Me Boutique$10
- Young Living$15
- Josie Maran$20
- Beekman 1802$22
- Flower Beauty$12
- Nakery Beauty$12
- Tatcha$25
- Mischo Beauty$18
- Truly$24
- bareMinerals$16
- It Cosmetics$19
- LipSense$18
- RealHer$18
- Grande Cosmetics$12
- The Unbranded Brand$15
Top brands in Makeup
Nearby categories
- Makeup$18
- Skincare$20
- Bath & Body$20
- Bags$31
- Accessories$18
- Tops$18
- Shoes$30
- Jewelry$22
- Dresses$25
- Jackets & Coats$30
- Pants & Jumpsuits$24
- Sweaters$24
More resale prices
About these numbers
Months of supply
Poshmark listings live on the date the block shows (every seller, not only Closo shops), divided by an average month of the 12-month sales in “What Maybelline New York makeup sells for”. Under 3 months is a seller's market, 3 to 6 balanced, over 6 a buyer's. Asks are listings up for under 90 days — a listing up longer is left out of them; a sold price is the item's last listed price, not the accepted offer.
Maybelline New York — questions buyers ask
Answers come from live Closo listings and real sales, not from marketing copy.
Closo resellers list 170 Maybelline New York pieces right now. 24 wholesale lots carry Maybelline New York on the manifest or in the listing, from vetted U.S. liquidators with escrow on every order.
How much do Maybelline New York makeup sell for?
How much are Maybelline New York makeup worth?
Where can I buy Maybelline New York makeup wholesale or in bulk?
Where do these prices come from?
All Maybelline New York wholesale lots
Every live lot carrying Maybelline New York on its manifest or in its listing — pallets and case packs from vetted U.S. liquidators. Escrow-protected, freight quoted to your ZIP.
Sorted by Recommended
Resale view — median sold price, last 12 months. New vs new, used vs used.
2.3× resale / costSteady seller
5.4× resale / costSteady seller
No resale estimate for this lotWe only show resale figures we can stand behind
No resale estimate for this lotWe only show resale figures we can stand behind
No resale estimate for this lotWe only show resale figures we can stand behind
No resale estimate for this lotWe only show resale figures we can stand behind
No resale estimate for this lotWe only show resale figures we can stand behind
No resale estimate for this lotWe only show resale figures we can stand behind
No resale estimate for this lotWe only show resale figures we can stand behind
No resale estimate for this lotWe only show resale figures we can stand behind
3.3× resale / cost100+ sold recently
3.3× resale / cost100+ sold recently
No resale estimate for this lotWe only show resale figures we can stand behind
No resale estimate for this lotWe only show resale figures we can stand behind
No resale estimate for this lotWe only show resale figures we can stand behind
2.6× resale / cost100+ sold recently
No resale estimate for this lotWe only show resale figures we can stand behind
No resale estimate for this lotWe only show resale figures we can stand behind
No resale estimate for this lotWe only show resale figures we can stand behind
No resale estimate for this lotWe only show resale figures we can stand behind
No resale estimate for this lotWe only show resale figures we can stand behind
No resale estimate for this lotWe only show resale figures we can stand behind
3.0× resale / cost100+ sold recently
Looking for something specific?
Describe the inventory you want to buy — we’ll source it and email you when a matching lot goes live.
- 1Describe it onceCategory, brand, and how much you buy.
- 2We go lookingAcross the liquidators who supply Closo Wholesale.
- 3You get one emailThe moment a matching lot goes live.
No account needed. Leave your email and we reply there.
About Maybelline New York wholesale on Closo
Maybelline New York wholesale on Closo is 24 live lots from 4 vetted U.S. suppliers, shipping from NJ, FL and MD. The lots sit on the cosmetics & beauty and general merchandise shelves. 100% of the graded lots are new with tags.
Read moreShow less
Prices start at $1.65 a piece. Every lot lists the supplier's manifest or assortment notes, the unit count, freight to your ZIP and Closo's own resale comps for Maybelline New York.
Maybelline New York lots — questions buyers ask
What buyers ask before they take a lot of this brand.
Are these genuine Maybelline New York goods?
Every lot is sold by a vetted U.S. liquidator or distributor and lists Maybelline New York on its manifest or in the supplier's own listing; the lot page shows the supplier, their reviews and the manifest lines. Payment sits in escrow until you accept delivery.
What is the minimum order for Maybelline New York wholesale?
One lot — a case pack or a pallet as the supplier packed it, from $1.65 a piece. There is no account minimum and no membership.
How much does shipping cost?
Freight is quoted to your ZIP on the lot page before you pay; Maybelline New York lots ship from NJ, FL and MD. Parcel-size lots ship parcel.